I definitely don't mean to diminish the contribution of the Gates Foundation though. I often hear that they're one of the good ones.
I definitely don't mean to diminish the contribution of the Gates Foundation though. I often hear that they're one of the good ones.
Sometimes democracy is wrong. More social programs, less F35s.
As a percentage of income tax receipts, the number for military spending is closer to 25%. See, for example, https://www.nationalpriorities.org/interactive-data/taxday/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_...
"Military budget of the United States. ... The budget funds 4 branches of the U.S. military: the Army, Marine Corps, Navy, and Air Force. In FY 2015, Pentagon and related spending totaled $598 billion, about 54% of the fiscal year 2015 U.S. discretionary budget."
Yes, we're spending that much on the military. Yes, its pathetic. Yes, its why its best to avoid (not evade, which is illegal) paying income tax whenever possible. I prefer my welfare programs not enable the slaughter of hundreds of thousands of civilians in a foreign country, but that's just me.
"U.S. discretionary spending" is simply spending which is authorized annually instead of authorized by laws spanning multiple years. It doesn't seem to be a highly meaningful categorization if you are arguing about where your dollars are going -- the dollars don't care what year they were authorized to be spent.
Separating out payroll vs income taxes -- in other words recognizing the different tax rates for "earned" vs. "unearned" income -- is not entirely irrelevant, because dollar for dollar your capital gains taxes will be spent more on defense than welfare, but it's still no where near 50% of your capital gains taxes being spent on defense.
So that's not entirely how income vs payroll taxes work.
If you get a paycheck, out comes taxes for social security and Medicare. There is an annual limit on how much of your income is taxed for social security, whereas there is no limit for Medicare, and there's a bump in the Medicare rate after a very high dollar amount (near $250k/year if I recall). For our argument, none of the above is refundable (if you pay too much social security tax because of multiple W2 employers, the extra tax gets applied to your federal income liability).
For income tax, lots of people pay through their paycheck, although if you're below a certain yearly income threshold, federal income tax is not withheld (you even get a refundable tax credit for working if you're poor enough). Also, as you mentioned, capital gains taxes also are federal income tax revenue. So, income tax is not unearned income alone.
"A key federal budget trick is using words to confuse citizens, such as labeling U.S. military spending as “defense” though much is for “offense” and sliding costs for wounded soldiers under “veterans affairs” and nuclear bombs under “energy,” as ex-CIA analyst Paul R. Pillar explains..."
Also, from [2]:
"The most recent figures related to President Trump’s proposed increases in Pentagon spending, along with cuts at the State Department, show the general national security budget of the United States rising once again, with the 2018 proposal in the ballpark of $1.1 trillion."
Finally, see [3], where the budget breakdown is:
The Pentagon budget - $575 billion
The war budget - $64.6 billion
Nuclear warheads - $20 billion
‘Other Defense’ - $8 billion
Homeland security - $50 billion
Military aid - $7 billion
Intelligence - $70 billion
Supporting veterans - $186 billion
Military retirement - $80 billion
Defense share of interest on the debt - $100 billion
[1] - http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article33833.htm
[2] - http://www.veteransnewsnow.com/2017/06/02/1015056-the-milita...
[3] - https://warisboring.com/the-trillion-dollar-military-budget/
I'm only one person, and my one vote carries little weight.
> Lower taxes on the wealthy doesn't keep the government from spending on defense, it just runs up a deficit that is then used as an excuse to cut non-defense spending (research, infrastructure, food for the impoverished, etc.).
I'm not against higher taxes, but I'm also not against the wealthy avoiding taxes in the case of Gates and Buffett (and for other reasons, Elon Musk, using his wealth to drive progress forward) when their wealth are going to social causes. If you can't adjust how the federal gov budgets, starve the beast until competent representatives are in office while doing good for those in need.
In Europe you still get more social programs, less f35... (not everywhere though).
Pensions 996.0
Health Care 1,121.2
Education 126.2
Defense 829.1
Welfare 377.2
Protection 37.7
Transportation 92.4
General Government 52.5
Other Spending 79.2
Interest 240.0
Total Spending 3,951.3
Defense as % of total: 21.3% (851.8/3999.5)
Defense as % of total minus social programs: 57.3% (851.8 / (3999.5-1011.6-1107.4-393.2) )
Note, the programs listed under Pensions, Health Care, and Welfare account for 62.8% of the budget. While you are correct in your statement, I don't like your conclusion. We should spend the 2.5 trillion on social programs more effectively not try and 3.3 trillion the same way.
https://www.nationalpriorities.org/campaigns/us-military-spe...
https://media.nationalpriorities.org/uploads/wolrd_military_...
"The U.S. outpaces all other nations in military expenditures. World military spending totaled more than $1.6 trillion in 2015. The U.S. accounted for 37 percent of the total.
U.S. military expenditures are roughly the size of the next seven largest military budgets around the world, combined."
We spend too much on military spending, full stop.
EDIT: Sidenote: Social security and Medicare very efficient as-is. They simply need more resources.
The more I read about this, the more I come around to the idea that charitable tax deductions should be ended entirely (actually I think all tax deductions should be phased out, but that's a bigger topic). It's effectively just another regressive tax.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howard_Hughes_Medical_Institut...