The Myth That Without Gov't Subsidies, Discoveries Will Be Hidden By Secrets
techdirt.com
techdirt.com
Or, the best example I can think of, is about a therapy for panic disorder (a psychological disorder). There is a remarkable effective talk therapy for panic disorder which cures 80+% of the people who have it, and those people stay cured years after they complete the therapy (and there is no evidence it ever returns). The most effective drug treatments cure much fewer than half of the people, and once those people stop taking the drugs, the panic tends to return. The studies comparing drugs and talk therapy are incredibly expensive, and almost all of them come out of England, paid for by the government. What private company would ever want to fund that sort of research? They have an highly profitable drug treatment, which is effectively addictive (if you stop it, the panic returns)? Why would they spend their own money to research a course of therapy that lasts 8-12 weeks and is then done?
I don't think private research is a bad thing at all. But private research is profit driven, and there are some really important problems out there that don't have a big financial payoff once they're solved. Economically speaking, finding a more effective to regrow hair in bald men would probably be a lot more profitable than finding a cheap cure for any number of diseases ravaging Africa. Doesn't mean it's more important.
Evidence that psychotherapy beats drugs would benefit these guys: http://www.americanpsychotherapy.com/
These guys would probably like to know which method of treatment is not worth paying for: http://www.ahip.org/
[Edit: kinda curious why I'm being downmodded for this.]
In the long run, there are far more values in curing ravaging diseases in Africa than there are values in curing bald hair men, at least to me.(Less disease ravaging means more time for educations, which might mean economic growth, which might mean bigger markets) For a corporation, it might make more sense to cure bald men instead of people in Africa. But it doesn't make sense for a charity organization to cure bald men instead of people in Africa because of their different aim.
Private research doesn't have to be profit...err money driven, but it can be done for err..noble reasons.
What to prevent billionaire from spending money on non...errr..profit research. Indeed, you would expect millionaires and billionaires to donate money to causes that seriously affect their life, whether it is themselves or a love one.
So what if it is viewed in economic lights? You're only looking at it in one perspective, which is how to make a lot of money. What you did forget is the true motivations why humans pursue money, like being able to live longer, have fun, being curious, have sex, etc.
Nothing, of course. But I would rather not rely on the generosity of billionaires to cure the diseases that ravage Africa.
Remember - the money has to come from somewhere.
In other words, the politician invests taxes where "we" want them to. So the proper question is not whether some politician wants to help poor nations, but whether we want to help them.
And that's quite a fair question, which is of a much higher quality than the question whether some individual (billionaire) wants to help them.
(After all, taxes are our money and politicians are "just" managing it for us.)
The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, on the other hand, is completely focussed on outcomes.
I mean, at worst, only 51% will get their money spent on things they thought are great noble causes.(Let just assume that every Noble Cause is important) That's not taking into consideration on weather the politicians are managing it wisely.
It would be really great if that was possible. However, we can't simply buy "$1 worth of helping poor nations" in the way we buy products in the supermarket. And that's why we can't "vote" with our money. (The appearance of micro payments might change that, though.)
So we have to trust some organization with the money, and that leads to exactly the same issues of trust.
However, the government is under greater pressure and control than most other organizations. Or, at least they should, in a democracy. So trusting them with the money is not worse than trusting any other help organization with the money - except, of course, when you know the people of the help organization personally. But most people don't have such connections.
Beside, democracies suck in actuality. Theory doesn't mean much of anything if they don't work in reality. The Californians vote for programs but not for higher taxes. There are whole lot of lobbying that's going on. Who have time to read thousand pages bills made by congressmen?
Well, theoretically with a democratic government, the decision to do things for the public good comes ultimately from the "will of the people" rather than the largess of billionaire. Now whether it actually works out that way is another question.
Still, American publicly funded research has produced a huge number of public benefits while involving a rather small percentage of public expenditure.
This is a nice theory, but who is voting on such minor issues, when you have wars, economic turmoil &c.? Absent voter pressure, isn't the reality is that such allocations are determined by lobbying?
> a rather small percentage of public expenditure.
Doesn't the suggestion of crowd-out point to an unexamined cost, which is the opportunity cost of the researchers? What would they be doing if not directed by government monies? If their efforts are being applied sub-optimally, what cost does that represent?
If it weren't for government funding, brilliant mathematicians might be making the bucks on Wall Street. It's Wall Street's loss and "society's" gain.
That illustrates to me that, contrary to the article, not all goods are private goods.
-- and it's not nice to quote people without including their caveats.
The financial sector no longer operates under standard free market rules given TBTF and thus the outsize profits that continue to attract highly educated graduates to Wall Street are secured by fear of total financial collapse.
Under the same rules that all other businesses play by, collapse would wipe out the bad players and free up tremendous resources for new enterprises to start - something that did not occur in the case of Wall Street.
Thus, aspects of Wall Street shape it to appear as another form of government funding/regulation that crowds out real free market enterprises from hiring those brilliant mathematicians.
> contrary to the article, not all goods are private goods
Funny that you decry my quoting you, then credit the article with claims it does not make. What economic thinker believes there are no club, common or public goods? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_goods#Terminology.2C_and...
Not something I support. Basic science is an example of a real public good. "The financial system not collapsing" was only a demagogic pseudo-public good.
No everything the often corrupt US government does is a public good but that hardly proves research is not a public good. The private sector's willingness to facilitate said corrupt government actions doesn't make me believe said private sector would produce more public benefit if a state functions were fully dismembered into it.
-- You are right in the one point, I should have said above, "contrary to the article, public research provides a public good".
I'm a much more rational spender of money I've already given to the government than I am of my own. I think the same holds for most people, to be honest.
Frankly, I find charity to be much more meaningful when I give it out of my free will, rather than making the government do it for me. Rather, government spending defeat the point of charity.
For me, the merits of charity is also about their voluntary nature in addition to the "warm fuzziness feeling".
On the other hand, I suspect that our disagreement is in respect to both utilitarian merits and moral/ethical philosophy.
(When I say for your own good, I mean what's for your own good long-term. Cheating, stealing, lying, etc., is ruled out, because that's not in anyone's self-interest, long-term.)
How does this endorse a lack of moral conscience or antisocial behavior? On what grounds do you judge your morality as better than mine? At the very least, do you think that you have to think about morality rationally, as I do?
Of course, it's easy to sneer at the wal-mart or Henry Ford people of the world. However, remember that they have made it much easier to help people by increasing productivity.
An engineer who built a safe water supply system has saved more people than most doctors in the world. A sanitation company has saved lives by preventing the accumulation of trash and by disposing it safely. All of which are occupations that are unseen to the public eyes.
Doctors, we can see. Doctors who work on charity, we can see. But what we can't see is those profiteers who nonetheless help people but are in the background.
Great, but that's not the question.
Max's assertion was that there is no nobler thing than doing something for a profit. That's simply not true.
Well, I would argue that everything I do, altruistic or not, goes back to satisfying my selfishness. In that point of view, selfishness is a human condition, not something to be ashamed of.
It is also part of the human condition to have social relations with other human beings. Sometime, that might mean caring for others even if we receive no hedonistic benefits. It's quite essential to our health, really.
Instead of saying that we must sacrifice one person for the good for the group, people would say that it's deplorable that somebody have to die.
In theory, I would not force someone to die, unless they volunteer to do so.
Of course, it might be different when I am placed in the actual situation itself.
It's like asking the person to make a decision between crashing into a man to save the lives on board the train or make a decision to swerves but endanger everyone in the train.
We're not talking here about forcing people to do anything - we're saying what is noble, and what is not. My argument is that nobility is taking the group rational decision. This may sometimes mean sacrificing one's own immediate desires.
> Economically speaking, finding a more effective to regrow hair in bald men would probably be a lot more profitable than finding a cheap cure for any number of diseases ravaging Africa. Doesn't mean it's more important.
The problem with this line of reasoning is the implicit assumption that it's your job to decide what's important. (BTW, you could probably send the money you spend on internet access each month to Africa, and save a child/mo. Be sure to reconcile that fact with your world view)
Many of the problems with pure capitalism stem from the fact that in practice, things don't work out as well as in theory, often because people aren't rational and information isn't symmetric. You should still try to understand how it's supposed to work.
But even if they found promising lines of research, they might be too nervous to provide enough funding...
what about them? the billions invested in them could have given us some tangible benefits in saving lives, directly or indirectly.
The problems of access to journals are real. My PhD supervisor and other researchers I knew were making a real effort to work around them by publishing a lot of papers on public online "e-print journals" like arxiv.org
The problems of access to conferences on the other hand, I never saw. If fact, at every conference I went to while I was doing my PhD, there was always a handful of uninvited people who tagged along. Often they were nuts who believed they were close to a proof of something actually improvable and wanted to find a professor to show their work to. Occasionally they were just highly motivated amateur mathematicians. Either way, they were always at least tolerated from what I saw.
In both cases, public monies realigned the efforts of those associated to seek and maintain the public monies first, which are not necessarily related to progress whatsoever. That is, building a army of bureaucrats for any space launch, in the case of NASA, and pulling would-be African entrepreneurs away from productive efforts and toward positions in the bureaucracies best-positioned to receive and distribute the aid within Africa.
If African aid money can devastate Africa by pulling the best and brightest into unproductive bureaucratic positions, then it's certainly plausible that research aid can pull the best and brightest away from the most productive pursuits and toward whatever the distributors of public money happen to demand, productive or not.
I don't believe we would have made it to the moon if only private enterprise had been involved, nor sent probes to the planets and the outer edges of the solar system. Those are very worthwhile accomplishments.
But, yes, I do believe NASA's time is coming to an end. We do seem to be reaching a point where private concerns are ready to push space exploration to the next level, and that's very exciting!
I think in general the way we fund things shouldn't necessarily be an either/or question. I can think of other examples where something needed to be publicly funded up to a certain point in its development, and then equally needed to be wrestled away from a public-funding model so that private businesses to keep it moving forward.
Both are relatively "applied". The "basic science" would be a bit harder to have funded - abstract math research, basic physics research, marine biological research.
Now, I would actually say the government should be spending more on basic research and less on applied research but that's an entirely different question.
Most basic research has payoff sooner or later. It's just fairly clear that the market isn't going to be financing things with a fifty years window.
You don't even have to go to the government to see the question-ability of the hands-off research bureacracy approach: compare Microsoft Research to Apple's technical efforts, or consider Xerox Park absent a few entrepreneurs to bring their efforts to market.
Research expresses its value in its application, and research funded by private means, for profit or charity, is far more likely to see its result applied to productive ends.
I can't tell you what sort of window for basic research private money would support, but I can tell you that connecting research to a meaningful expression is fundamental to the value of the research, and it would seem, far more likely to happen as a result of private funding.
[1] I'd argue NASA has exactly this sort of 'basic research' nature, in that its efforts pay out in the very long run. Now, this has not prevented them from devolving into what is essentially an inefficient, bureaucratic jobs program for the aerospace industry.
[2] The talk makes the point that basic research in math, science, &c. was funded long before government intervention, as a result of economic activity.
This is a really interesting point, notably with regards to NASA. From the outset, NASA was at its core a defense oriented expenditure - that is to say that it was imbued with an explicit purpose.
Fast-forward to the creation of the space shuttle and the thawing of space-relations with the Apollo-Soyuz docking in 1975. It seems that from this point forward that NASA's mission of human spaceflight had lost its way, characterized today by the morass that the space shuttle has become.
Obviously, in an optimal world, everyone would have equal access to all such knowledge - but there will always be barriers on both sides.
It's like saying that everyone should be a programmer, but people waste time trying to learn programs when they can hire a programmer to make a program for them. Then these people will do things that's worth their time such as making musics or cooking food.
Communists willfully ignore this fact.
Also, communism and socialism is, by far, not the same thing.