> You can't just pull numbers out of thin air to make your point.> Experience has shown us that antivirus software does not do what it says on the tin.
Whose experience?
I built WildFire at Palo Alto Networks[1]. We analyzed a few tens of millions of new potential threats daily, including the VirusTotal firehose.
As part of our internal efficacy and competitive monitoring, we took the top 5 enterprise antivirus products and ran everything coming into WildFire through them.
The delta between ground truth and what the antivirus engines caught using only static scanning and emulation was about a third, i.e. better than the pessimistic estimate of half I threw out. (In the real world, antivirus actually does better because malware is easier to catch after it starts running.)
The danger of antivirus, on the other hand, is wildly overstated in this thread. A small fraction of attacks use vulnerabilities to begin with, and in the scheme of things, very few antivirus vulnerabilities have been found. 1% is just a nice, round number chosen for illustrative purposes; it's orders of magnitude greater than the real risk.
Now, this will surprise exactly no one who works in security, since most new malware is a minor variant of existing malware and exploits are relatively uncommon, but for the less experienced folks reading these comments, I implore you: Don't listen to people who say antivirus is useless or, worse, makes you less secure.
It isn't. It doesn't. They're wrong.
1. It's the biggest ATP product out there, took the crown from FireEye c. 2015. https://www.paloaltonetworks.com/products/secure-the-network...