Imagine the nurse who spends her entire shift insertting IVs. Now imagine that she grows accustomed to working off a checklist everytime. Day in and day out she operates with a checklist for weeks and months on-end. Suddenly, a patient goes critical on her shift and she has seconds to insert a life-saving IV for fluids and medication. Can she operate efficiently without a checklist? I suspect the answer to that question is a resounding "no" and that her patient's life suffers as a result.
The situation isn't as cut and dry as I'm making it, that's for sure. No doubt there is incompetency and complacency all throughout the industry, and checklists could probably combat that effectively. I just think that mandating their use across the board in every circumstance will have unintended consequences that may very well cost lives.