Ethanol: A Lethal Injection for Tumors
acsh.org
acsh.org
You're probably wondering what the catch is if you haven't spotted it yet.
Ethanol ablation is usually used for carcinomas of the liver, although it sometimes sees use in some very rare cancers. So, this falls under the "extremely effective but with limited application" category. That doesn't mean it doesn't have great value, but you also don't want folk to think it's a "lethal injection for all tumours".
There is also a very honest list of caveats in the discussion,
"Although we have demonstrated the efficacy of enhanced ethanol ablation in the treatment of squamous cell carcinomas in the hamster cheek pouch, there are several limitations to this study. First, the use of a chemically-induced tumor model (in which spontaneous tumors arising in sites adjacent to a treated site would be indistinguishable from the original tumor) precluded the possibility of any long-term monitoring of tumor recurrence. Second, a single animal tumor model was utilized. Further study in other tumor models is needed to investigate such recurrence, and demonstrate therapeutic efficacy more broadly. Since this study was a proof-of-concept, sample sizes were relatively low. Although other studies have shown systemic safety of ethanol ablation in a variety of applications, more research is needed to investigate the possibility of damage to surrounding tissue. Leakage of ethanol and nearby necrosis should be minimized, and details may be specific to tumor types. Although ethyl cellulose-ethanol has been used in the treatment of venous malformations, further safety evaluations of injections to tumors are clearly necessary. The ethanol-ethyl cellulose-water system has shown promise; but its more complete characterization will inform optimization. For example, better understand- ing of physicochemical details of the sol-gel transition, e.g. involving pressure and temperature, will benefit from improved discrimination between the sol and gel phases. The mechanical phantoms proved helpful in this initial study. Follow up use of them can improve details of their poroelastic structures and properties, and thus improve their role in the design process for enhanced ethanol ablation."
US residents could perhaps travel abroad for the treatment. Maybe it will be offered in Mexico some day.
People think they can have their cake and eat it too with the FDA. The administration likely kills many people through opportunity cost. People really need to ask themselves if the FDA are the ones who should be making the decision whether something is risky enough that you shouldn't have access to it. In my eyes, if drug companies had standard product liability, then drugs would be safer and cheaper.
For every potentially legitimate treatment held back, a hundred illegitimate - if not harmful - treatments are also stopped. I won't claim this excuses the costs and time associated with getting FDA approval, but it's one more thing to consider when judging them.
Who cares? Homeopathy is largely harmless, the vast majority of people who practice it are not actually treating anything. Unless something goes seriously wrong, an extreme dilution is not going to have the same devastating effect as an untreated serious condition, unless the patient sticks it out like a fool, in which case can anyone except the charlatan who convinced them really be blamed?
Not if someone is relying on it (or other 'harmless' cures like faith healing) to treat their cancer, or their children's cancer, instead of something that will actually work it's not. Nor is it harmless if they have a contagious condition that they spread around (and you catch!) under the assumption that they've already been 'cured'. Nor is it harmless even if it's just emptying their wallet.
> Unless something goes seriously wrong, an extreme dilution is not going to have the same devastating effect as an untreated serious condition
Which I'd wager you'd agree happens more often than homeopathy goes seriously right, even ignoring the fool patients, parents, and caregivers who might leave serious conditions effectively untreated on account of believing in snake oil.
Not ignoring them, this was reported two days ago: https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/09/cdc-homeopathic-heal...
> in which case can anyone except the charlatan who convinced them really be blamed?
Some would argue that the society which stood idly by and refused to oppose such charlatans, if not to blame, is at least some kind of low trust, everyone for themselves, shitty kind of society. Especially if it can identify who is to blame, and still does nothing.
Government regulation is not the only tool of opposition. James Randi has given some good talks to help fight the ignorance they exploit with knowledge. (EDIT: His TED talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c0Z7KeNCi7g .) And there's some arguments that can be made that true freedom requires freedom to do stupid, counterproductive, self harming shit (although that's not the argument you're making.)
TL;DR: I disagree with you on your stance of how harmless homeopathy supposedly is.
Now imagine a creature, very intelligent, but due to the intelligence - emotionally and socially handicapped- and thus unable to procreate. Such a creature would be foolish, thinking in evolutionary terms. But such a creature, could be useful for a society, who would want them to stick around. So if a not-fool would pro-create with such a fuel, even if it is rare, that would be a nice little selection machine.
So if a procreation-fool, has foolish children, who in turn spawn procreation-fools, what a nice little dessert flower symbiosis that would be.
And that is why intelligent people could have dumb children.
The moral to this story: That fool clinging with cancer to charlatans, like Steve Jobs did- could be your future daughter or son.
With great intelligence, comes great responsibility for those who might not wield it. And the uncomfortable knowledge that seemingly foolish behavior might be intelligent for other applications.
Steve Jobs had a curable form of cancer. He chose homeopathy instead.
Let's not pretend this is an isolated case.
i was able to find this Scientific American article about Jobs, which mentions dietary changes and acupuncture, but it doesn't mention that he used homeopathy.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/alternative-medic...
is that documented somewhere else?
On a related note, why are pharmaceutical companies allowed to market drugs through television and print advertisements? Clearly, most of the target population doesn't have the necessary knowledge or resources to make an informed decision regarding whether or not they should be on the advertised drug as part of their treatment.
DTC ads help patients have better discussions with their physicians and provide greater awareness of treatments. The study demonstrated that when a patient asked about a specific drug, 88 percent of the time they had the condition that the drug treated. And 80 percent of physicians believed their patients understood what condition the advertised drug treats.[1]
[1]https://www.fda.gov/drugs/resourcesforyou/consumers/ucm14356...
(Very, very large quantities of it)