Of course, this system only worked because academia was a bastion of the male WASP elites that didn't have much pretense of serving the broader public. But at least you didn't have the torrent of mediocre papers that you see today.
Of course, this system only worked because academia was a bastion of the male WASP elites that didn't have much pretense of serving the broader public. But at least you didn't have the torrent of mediocre papers that you see today.
Have things really changed? I suspect there are fewer males, but any job that demands 20 years of full-time concerted effort is likely to be dominated by men. Similarly, the western world is overwhelmingly caucasian, so again... the best predictor (now as then) is that white male professors will be represented disproportionately.
> at least you didn't have the torrent of mediocre papers that you see today.
That certainly is true. Stats for the humanities and social sciences are that 80% of the papers have zero citations. i.e. they have no contribution to the greater body of human work.
In Physics (my background), most papers have 2-3 citations, and only a small percentage have 1 or fewer.
I would say that if a discipline is dominated by uncited papers, then that discipline is probably a waste of time. And the professors who work in it are a net drain on society.
> In Physics (my background), most papers have 2-3 citations, and only a small percentage have 1 or fewer
Does that account for self-citations?
No, it refers to White Anglo-Saxon Protestants, an ethno-religious group that cuts across socio-economic class divides and includes plenty of people that are neither old money nor descended from families that have been in the US since the founding (and excludes some old-money, from-the-founding families.)
But then you get the problem of selecting those people without easily measured objective indicators. That's why it worked reasonably well when those were slightly low paying jobs restricted to a caste.