You can set the standard as a middle ground, such as the web company knew or should have known their technology was being used to facilitate crimes (we are talking about specific crimes, not generally). I only used strict liability to highlight the most extreme counter example to EFF's position of no liability.
Take Uber in Florida. Many counties they operated (knowingly/willfully) illegally. They recruited drivers from counties where it was legal to counties it was illegal, paying bonuses to drivers to get them to comply. They ran software that would cancel rides if it determined: a. It was a LE operation; or b. The driver was working with LE. Uber created training materials to avoid LE in counties drivers were operating illegally and distributed them to said drivers (everything from have passengers sit up front, take your Uber phone down, etc...). Driver caught breaking the law more than twice are terminated.
Millions in fines to drivers, cars impounded, drivers arrested and charged criminally...but nothing happened to Uber, how is that a middle ground?
Non government entities oppose or try to influence existing laws in many ways and for many reasons. Some examples are BLM, congressional lobbying, and what Uber has done. Uber's fight is, of course, strictly for their bottom line, but the general principle of non government entities making change through non legislative channels applies.
Finally, you have to consider public opinion. Uber has had plenty of opposition, but I would say that, by and large, the public supports them because they provide a useful service. Your proposed "murder for hire platform" is both already illegal and would meet staunch public opposition.
If SESTA passes we will not only potentially criminalize many software projects, but also make some markets impossible to enter without a sizable amount of cash (ex: web hosting).
And that's the status quo everyone seems to be accepting because god forbid a startup needs more cash to compete in order to comply with laws.