> I hope it's not difficult to see why a change that directly impacts that might have negative consequences elsewhere.
Sure, but at the risk of repeating myself: That sounds like an implementation problem.
> I've heard no argument why the PTC mode should be intrinsically faster than the non-PTC mode
There's a simple one: Hitting the stack less means you hit less memory.
> The people you are disagreeing with (not I) are responsible about 85% of the JavaScript engines on the Internet, an incredibly competitive space with billions in funding. ... I'm sure they'd love a patch
Happy to oblige. I'll implement TCO on V8 for a billion dollars in a way that beats these benchmarks.
> However, you're asking me to prove a negative.
And you're making straw men instead: At the beginning of your response, it's not even clear you read my complaint, but at the end, it's quite clear.
The simple answer would probably have been "yes, it's about an implementation, but it remains unknown where else we can go", but instead you doubled down...