Well, the article does literally say "No people were laid off when the robots were installed, and Amazon found new roles for the displaced workers, Mr. Clark said.". Either Mr. Clark is lying, or this point is moot.
Well, the article does literally say "No people were laid off when the robots were installed, and Amazon found new roles for the displaced workers, Mr. Clark said.". Either Mr. Clark is lying, or this point is moot.
After the robots, they could have 115 employees working and still not laid anyone off. Yet, in terms of full time employment, they went from 150 to 115 and in terms of temp labor went from 150 to 0.
Did the robots destroy jobs in such a case? I'd think "yes". (I still support the deployment of robots in such cases; I'm only responding to the logical argument here, not the philosophical implications thereof.)
Why would they retain employees which they would not rehire (minus wages in place of hiring cost)? They have no obligation to retain these workers, so clearly Amazon's base (non-seasonal) demand for labour increases fast enough to justify retaining them. At the current rate you would expect them to hire more labour, not less. The human jobs described here are still so far beyond current robotic technology that it's likely there will be no easy gains in automation here. Meanwhile, as Amazon's efficiency increases, throughput will also increase, which means demand for labour will continue to increase even if there are marginal increases in automation.
For good relations with the Government which has a goal of decreasing unemployment, and avoiding bad PR in popular media? If you can wait a couple of months to achieve exactly the same outcome with fewer risks, why not.
> Meanwhile, as Amazon's efficiency increases, throughput will also increase
No, throughput is a function of demand, not efficiency, unless Amazon is currently backlogged.
This. Technically, centralisation has given amazon the scale to automate. Socially, that same scale of centralisation exposes them to more critical eyes. Their main vulnerability I guess...
The reallocation of labor during the throes of the industrial revolution worked because the new technologies needed constant care and babysitting. Reliable machines that need infrequent service will not need much maintenance staff.
It all sounds like wishful thinking or, indeed, a political PR spin.
It looks like they've used the automation to densify the shelving in the warehouse, and they've streamlined the picker and placer jobs. So the same square footage of warehouse, and same headcount, now has substantially more storage, and higher throughput.
Which probably allows savings on the number of facilities they need to operate, or at least the rate at which they build them.