In terms of cash, $1200 a year is a lot to me personally, I'm a student, I have no income, and I'm trying to bootstrap a startup. $1200 could feed me for a year. Even when I had my PhD stipend, $1200 was a months stipend.
I originally chose to use Caddy over NGINX because it made https easy: just download, configure, run. If I have to remove the sponsor code and build it myself, it loses the advantage it had over NGINX because now I've got to spent time creating a build script and updating it whenever Caddy makes changes. With NGINX, sure, I'll have to configure it and letsencrypt, but I'll only ever have to do that once.