And what's worse is when utility companies require me to "authenticate" over the phone with my name, address & dob: all publicly (to varying degrees) available information.
I'm usually let them tell their tale (out of my room, of course), ask a lot of questions, nod with them happily, and in the end I say thanks, but I'm sorry, I don't disclose my info, full stop. Their butthurt is sometimes too cool to watch without popcorn.
If I am who I say I am I should be able to answer all three without much thinking and answer naturally to my name.