Hacker News Reader

Comment by heroprotagonist | Hacker News Reader

I tried two QR readers on the photos in the article. They did not detect the code.

Would it have been much more effort for the photographer to take a photo that was scannable? Or is there just too much variance in the arrangement and no reader would actually scan it even without a photo?

View on HN

Barcode Scanner on Android gives:

http://weixin.qq.com/r/WD-i_pfE3sqhrdOZ92pK

Visiting that link simply forwards me to

http://www.wechat.com/mobile/en/

Rather anticlimactic.

That is exactly working as intended.

You need to install WeChat and use the app to scan it to go the official account of the tourism office.

Might be a problem with the combination of your monitor and your phone camera. I tried Barcode Scanner on Android, and it scanned it without a hitch. Hell, I had more trouble scanning a QR code I hand-drawn in blue on white paper...

Huh, that's kind of odd. I use QR codes for lots of other things and they are successful, though the images are typically more clear.

It's Chinese, if there's a QRCode you need to use Wechat. I tried and it's working fine.

For what it's worth, "Barcode Scanner" on Android was able to scan it effortlessly.

An old QR app I had for a long time (from when QR codes were first introduced, many years ago) failed to read it too. Some of the bits look ambiguous too --- e.g. taking the upper left corner bit of the upper left locator square to be (0,0), what's the bit at (16,11)? It's both noticeably darker and lighter than its neighbours, like it was cut out and then grew back slightly.

Those which can't read the code probably use traditional thresholding to reduce the input into 0-1 first, while those which can are using some variation of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft-decision_decoding algorithm.

It doesn't help either that the middle was blanked out, eating into the error correction budget.

I scanned it with WeChat and the public WeChatID of the company popped out - haomengshenghuo, whose direct translation of english is: life with good dreams.

It worked with the scanner in the built-in camera app in iOS 11, but I had to manually adjust the brightness (issue with scanning off a computer screen?)

It worked for me just fine using the QR Scanner on Wechat for QR code that leads to the "village's tourism account on WeChat".

It worked for me. Opens wechat in the Play store.

QR Droid worked fine.

So did Google Goggles.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com