You'll never really know your success rate though. You could have had machines compromised for years with small amounts of traffic.
Yes, there could have been compromises that went entirely undetected for years (we had a really high retention, so most customers stayed with us for 5+ years), so we had a good window to detect issues.
Probably the next biggest notification of compromise was alerts about spam on our network. Mostly that was an e-mail account compromise rather than system level. But there are a ton of false positives on spam alerts, particularly AOL alerts were almost always about legitimately sent e-mails.