I wonder how it would go in 3D. In 3D the relatively tiny Moon pieces have much smaller rate of hitting each other and fragment into smaller pieces.
The three main problems is space is 3d, moon fragments are going to be very soft, the sun is going to impact these orbits.
The likely result is the earth ends up with a huge amount of dust, but not many large impacts.
Another consideration the moon does not orbit the earths equator but Uranus, Saturn, and Jupiter's rings do. This suggest tidal forces play a major role and you would not end up with a ring in the same inclination as the Moon's orbit.