Which then will create people living completely double lives, the obedient shell one and the other one.
Which then will create people living completely double lives, the obedient shell one and the other one.
You can't discuss specific things if you never figured generic things out. We will have pointless discussions like "was is a good thing to murder this particular person, or you say it wasn't?"
Nobody figures generic things out. They're too generic for that. The true things you can say are trivial and the non-trivial things are untrue.
The grander and more general a topic, the fewer interesting things there are to say about it—especially in internet threads. Those few things get said over and over, making the threads predictable and boring. The solution is to avoid such tangents. To avoid a black hole, don't go near it.
https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...
That's what you are thinking.
But you know what HN users think? They think +24.
It's a really shitty thing to be dragged into the swamp by someone who is lost in it. But to acknowledge it's just this shitty thing, nothing more, like cancer or falling down the stairs, that just hurt and diminished you for no good reason and for no real good outcome, which kept you from what is rightfully yours -- yourself -- that is step one. It's painful and can be paralyzingly scary, yet if people could see how scarier what they're regressing into is, how it's just a dead end filled with pain, in comparison to the soundness waiting beyond that small scary threshold, they'd take it in a heartbeat.
Unfortunately, my first reaction to someone wanting to "sell" me abuse or obedience is anger. But it really should be compassion.. obedient and authoritarian people deserve better. Abused and abusive people deserve better. FWIW I didn't think much of China when I wrote this; people break in the same dozens of ways all over the world and all through history it seems. But compassion and giving it just one inch are still orthogonal, you have to balance between the feelings of those who are fucked up, and those they would hurt by virtue of being so.
First it's "no outright porn" then "no naming of private parts" then "no blurring of line between good and evil".
You can imagine their conditions as an area, and your meaningful life as an area, and the Venn diagram of those two stops intersecting. You can't write "Crime and Punishment" without blurring line between good and evil. You can't write about any problems you are having. So now you are writing something banal, bland and unconvincing (as most of communist art is)
Also, "don't do drugs" is not usually a law, unless in repressive jurisdictions. You can't sell drugs and perhaps possess large quantities, but you can do drugs as an adult making choices.
Google defines obedience as:
> compliance with an order, request, or law or submission to another's authority
So going by that definition, following the law is indeed "obedience". Similarly, complying with a court order would also be "obedience", as would pulling over to the side of the road when a police officer drives behind you with their lights and siren on, or listening to a lifeguard at a pool when they tell everyone to get out of the water.
In fact, if we're going by the dictionary definition of obedience, I would argue that obedience is necessary for the very existence of civilized society.
That's the idea behind Chinese "points for obedience" system, isn't it?
I don't think being obedient and "trying to internalize other entity's command as your own behaviour" is the exact same thing (one might overlap - that I agree).
I hope you don't laugh because that's exactly you are trying to convey.
No that doesn't work that way, and dictionary won't help you. For starters, you should understand the distinction between action and inaction.
Then you should take on personal borders topic.