How often do you get arrested where that edge case is a legitimate concern?
If being arrested were a legitimate concern, why would you keep data on your phone that would implicate you in a crime?
If you were in a higher risk group (i.e. a drug dealer,) why not disable Face ID? Use a six digit pin and be done with it.
I am not particularly worried about cops, I am worried about losing my phone and having some jackass using my data to fill his bank account.
Political dissidents are the group I'm concerned about. Police are very interested in extracting contact lists from activists' phones in order to build a model of their social networks and infiltrate/disrupt them. This is a pervasive problem.
Yes, the answer is to get people to turn off FaceID if they're at risk, but educating large groups of at-risk people is hard, and it would be better if this feature were not turned on by default.
You already have to educate them to use a password, is it that hard to say ‘and don’t use biometrics either’?
And does it matter? If a government wants to repress they’ll do it. They’ll beat you or harass you or something like that.
“Well we think you’re trying to overthrow us but FaceID is turned off on your phone. I guess we’ll give up today. You’re free to go, have a nice time. ”
I agree that the description you provide is generally correct.
Your understanding of the current state of the law is very wrong.
There's a person in the US [0] who has been in jail for multiple years now without being tried / convicted due to refusing to provide access to their devices.
There's another case with a warrant[1] allowing an officer to force someone to unlock their phone protected by TouchID.
I have also heard multiple US states have enacted laws specifically addressing device unlock, but I don't have links to them at the moment.
[0] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/08/man-in-jail-2-ye...
[1] http://files.cloudprivacy.net/la-iphone-fingerprint-warrant....
That is a very wrong statement. I don’t care if things changed a year or more ago, it doesn’t make it any less wrong now. I of course meant no offense to you, but legal statements which are wrong could easily mislead someone and the emphasis is necessary. Apologies if offense was taken!
So a PIN alone would've been more secure. It'd have cost the government more effort to crack. A strong password or TOTP would've been a better solution. Pref. 2FA w/both.
You could use FaceID as 2FA, but then people need to keep in mind that its a very weak chain in the 2FA. They still need a strong other factor ie. a strong password.
You know how and where Ross Anderson was busted?
This is peanuts to beat. You bust the target whilst they're on a dinner having a drink, or right after they went asleep. The government knows your current position, and knows when you're asleep. Once this has become the status quo, rest assured cops with a police warrant wouldn't enter anymore at 6 AM right before you wake up but at 1 AM right after you went asleep (but before your FaceID would time out).
> (which would be very rare since it would just require you to squeeze both sides and you'd have the chance to do that while performing the action of handing your phone over).
Law enforcement will adapt very quickly to that if this becomes the status quo. They'll first and foremost bust your hands, so that you are unable to lock your phone. Then they hold the phone before you and voila, unlocked.
In encryption terms, logging in with biometrics is "vs. kid sister" security, not "vs. major government" security.
> If you are so concerned about security that you think there is a good chance someone is going to physically attack you to get into your phone, you should just assume someone will get into your phone eventually, and don't keep any sensitive data on it. For the other 99.9999% of the population, face id is good enough.
I don't understand this statistic. Are you arguing 99.9999% of all phones aren't a potential target of being stolen? Are you arguing 99.9999% of all people's data isn't interesting to authorities? You're being overly optimistic about FaceID.
No, I'm saying that, for effectively everyone, there are way easier ways to get into their phone than through FaceID, for example by just taking their phone while they are using it. So for effectively everyone, FaceID will not change their security risk, because there is no motivation for anyone to try and bypass their FaceID when there are easier attack vectors - especially when you are able to disable FaceID the second you feel you are being threatened.