Craigslist Valuation: $80 Million in 2008 Revenue, Worth $5 Billion
alleyinsider.com
alleyinsider.com
While I think the article is more than a hyperbolic with its projected revenues and valuation, I certainly think a valuation of a few billion would be fair, especially when you consider Skype was bought for €1.9b, YouTube was bought for $1.65b and Bebo was bought for $850m.
What is he smoking? Sure they have a lot of page views, but man, you can do a lot for $50 million a year. Craigslist's site is as bare as it could be. All static html, that is probably just generated using whatever scripting language it wants. I'm there is some engineering challenges and that they go through a good bit of bandwidth, but i mean, I feel like this guy is off by like an order of magnitude. Now, I don't know squat about serious big iron servers and doing stuff that large, but its definitely not $50million to run it. A guy in the site's comments puts the yearly cost at $1 million and he even over-estimates a bit in my book.
Also, all these analysts always speculate about how much money craigslist could make if they charged for all job postings and ads. As soon as they started charging for anything more than what they do they would probably get an order of magnitude less postings. Then they would just another monster.com/careerbuilder.com/etc crappy clone. Whats great now is that people can post whatever they want for free, with the few exceptions that help pay for it all (and still probably make Craig rich). The author obviously didn't study engineering or physics because his back-of-the-envelope calculations suck.
Text-only = everyone's best interest!
Also, his definition of startup is a bit off -- Craigslist shouldn't be included in this group.
- Uncertain data: "We've struggled to get formal business metrics for Craigslist"
- Assumptions -- count how many times he says "let's assume"
- Doesn't acknowledge potential competition
- Doesn't note that Newmark has repeatedly ruled out selling Craigslist
You don't think these are problematic?
In fact, the whole article is pretty specious. 'Value', as ex-analyst Blodget surely knows, can refer to either the price someone else will pay for an asset, or the present value of the future cash flows generated by that asset. The first one doesn't make sense because Newmark says he won't sell; the second invalidates all of the assumptions in the article because Newmark appears determine to run it the way he likes it. By that standard, CL is probably worth something like $250 million.