Misparse, I think. Both "was"es refer to the state of using 7 being defensible. Maybe a better phrasing: Using 7 would have remained defensible as long as it had security support, but now even that's insufficient. Alternatively, the parent argues that 7 is de facto unsupported now no matter what Microsoft claims.
This is a great breakdown. Are you using any specific cognitive techniques or patterns/habits that help you do this?
I suspect reading... and Poe's law.
Less crunchy than Cole's Law.
That’s some delicious snark and all, but if it were only that simple. In general, most people tend to be oblivious to—perhaps even motivated to miss—when the source of a disagreement might be linguistic confusion rather than actual disagreement.