Ask HN: Is Agile that good?
Everytime someone is arguing that Agile sucks, the answer is always: your are doing Agile wrong.
So Agile is the only best methodology ?
It's not a specific description of right things.
Therefore, it's almost impossible to say that a project is really agile, or just taking on the trappings of agile without "really" understanding it. What usually happens is that the successful ones are called agile, and those that failed aren't.
This is the No True Scotsman fallacy.
While dated, I still recommend "Rapid Development" as a great source for describing the variety of development practices that you might use.
Compare code: there's no "only best" way to structure your code, but most everybody would agree that a 3000-line long "main" function with one-letter-named global variables is probably Doing It Wrong.