Its a solid proposal, but I guess its up to the courts to decide if "Efficiency Gap" is a good metric. I guess I'll be interested in hearing the arguments as they come up.
Its a solid proposal, but I guess its up to the courts to decide if "Efficiency Gap" is a good metric. I guess I'll be interested in hearing the arguments as they come up.
I've always thought they should just reverse the order of operations. Instead of having people draw the districts, then machines evaluate them, they should have machines draw a bunch of potential "low efficiency gap" districts, then let people pick the best ones.
If a machine gave you a crazy-shaped district map because that's the only way to get "low efficiency gap", would you agree to them?
[0] https://www.census.gov/history/pdf/2010questionnaire.pdf Page 2 question #6.
Also, the concept of a 'blue/red' district can be very blurry - there are many examples of 'blue' districts (districts with democrat congress reps, and a history of voting blue) that voted red in the last presidential election, and vice-versa for previous elections.
Historically, Americans prefer to vote for people, not parties.
Should a new highway replace the housing development over there? Well, people who live close to that housing development might care one way or the other (Noise complaints, Ecological issues, Traffic Issues). People who live very far away from that center probably don't care at all. And the people who live in the housing development (who will be forced to move out), especially renters who probably won't be properly compensated, will care the most.
The placement of schools, the budgets of police, the design of zoning regulations (in particular "Enterprise Zones" of lower taxes to encourage business development in some areas)... these all are innately local issues.
But that create inefficiencies as that heavily favour some parties. So we have a chunk of undistricted delegates that are given out to even out the overall proportionality. This get you pretty good results as long as the amount of parties stay within reasonable boundaries[].
[] Which they of course haven't - we currently have 8 parties in the Riksdag.
100% agree. I think this can be further broken down into the questions:
(1) What are the problems caused by extreme gerrymandering?
(2) How will efficiency gap minimization alleviate these problems?
(3) What assumptions are we making in (2)? How likely are they to be true? And how robust is the solution to their falsification?
(4) How could this all go catastrophically wrong?
My intuition is that efficiency gap minimization is an incomplete solution and probably should be only one of several factors considered.