Apply your comment to Harvey Weinstein and see if you can give him a pass on an "incredible waste of talent and ability"
Apply your comment to Harvey Weinstein and see if you can give him a pass on an "incredible waste of talent and ability"
I simply think that in general locking people up is inefficient, ineffective, and immoral. There are certainly exceptions IMHO; I'm not an absolutist on this. But I think the actual cases that justify incarcerations are a small percentage of what we currently have.
Imo, both are weak argument to treat that person any different if that person really commuted crime that would put less great hacker to prison.
Hard work and a great mind have nothing to do with the justification for not imprisoning him. Those come into play when considering the waste to society as a result of locking him up. I can see how the two positions were conflated, but hopefully this clarifies.
However what I haven't really waivered on is my resonance with Enlightenment values, especially John Stuart Mill. I like a lot of what Michael Shermer has to say regarding a scientific basis for morality. He has a book called The Moral Arc: How Science and Reason Lead Humanity toward Truth, Justice, and Freedom which I find quite interesting.
Ultimately this may be the best ground on which to attack my argument, since it is a tripartite argument and one of those is based on morality. I will cede that the argument from morality is subjective, and ultimately some form of argument from authority which is a weak case.
Though, you could make this argument with Bill Cosby. World-class talent who went on a decades-long campaign of rapes and sexual assaults. Many people might now feel distraught their idol was a monster.
Success as a producer probably involves significant skill/talent, of a similar kind that drives success in other organizational/leadership roles.