That's an interesting point of view. Certainly in office situations some of the most useful and enlightening conversations I have happen in a "water cooler" type setting. Cigarette break perhaps. Indeed, when I gave up smoking, I changed to chewing gum in the smoking area. The people who meet in random places spark new ideas, bring parts of a business (or community) together who ordinarily would have no reason to meet.
I certainly hear your point about addictiveness of comment ratings, but I think the value of randomly mediated conversation is huge. (As an aside, I started putting together a business presentation on how watching who talks to each other on a smoke break, water cooler run, etc. has valuable lessons for where communication lines may be missing in your organisation. Not always, sure, but there's hints there)