(Which is to say, I wouldn't be concerned about making it illegal if it stopped being so effective.)
Otherwise they'd only target doctors, in their offices, trade mags and all. http://www.businessinsider.com/infographic-america-is-over-m...
Stats say that we're way over prescribed.
- Many physicians thought that DTC ads made their patients more involved in their health care.
- The study demonstrated that when a patient asked about a specific drug, 88 percent of the time they had the condition that the drug treated.
Of course the study showed there were problems, but it was the ads had many more positive effects than negative!
[1]https://www.fda.gov/Drugs/ResourcesForYou/Consumers/ucm14356...
* 58% of respondents "agreed strongly that DTC ads make the drugs seem better than they really are"
* 78% of physicians believed patients understood possible benefits, however, only 40% believe patients understood the risks involved.
* 75% of "physicians surveyed believed that DTC ads cause patients to think that the drug works better than it does"
* "physicians felt some pressure to prescribe something when patients mentioned DTC ads."
So, patients are getting more involved and asking questions, which is great, but they don't understand the risks involved, the patient misrepresents how well the drug is working for them, and the physician feels pressure to give them what they ask for.
That sort of bias is a problem, especially with on-going therapy. If a patient is being misled by DTC ads about how well they are being treated, they can't raise questions that would allow them to get even better treatment. If a physician is feeling pressured to give a drug when asked, they can't try other, sometimes more effective, therapies.
I guess my point is that most people see DTC ads as completely useless and harmful overall.
The study seems to suggest there are a lot of positive benefits.
One point I didn't copy paste showed that of the 80% of patient who actually had the condition, 5% were previously undiagnosed! That means a drug ad potentially saved thei life if it was a serious disease!
The DTC ads aren't completely useless, but they are harmful.
A patient is unable to understand that the drug is putting them at risk. 60% of people can't see their side-effects as side-effects. So dangerous side-effects like angina and depression take longer to diagnose, leaving the patient at-risk.
A patient is showing a placebo effect, so the doctor cannot tell how well the drug is working. That means, if it's a serious disease, they might be getting worse, but are unable to identify it, and for staged illnesses, that can mean more important treatment comes too late.
Remember, self-reporting is still the primary way we convey to doctors what's happening with us. If it can't be trusted to be accurate, the doctor can't be as effective as they need to be.
Not sure I understand. The survey was asking doctors if they think patients understand the risks from seeing the ad. Doctors think they do.
But patients then need to go and talk to the doctor, who should then clarify the risks since they are the medical professional, not the patient.
If the patient then decides the risks are worth it, and the doctor thinks the drug will help, the doctor writes a prescription.
Plainly, you read a different study than I.
This direct quote, directly disagrees with you:
> Seventy-eight percent of physicians believe their patients understand the possible benefits of the drug very well or somewhat, compared to 40 percent who believe their patients understand the possible risks, and 65 percent believe DTC ads confuse patients about the relative risks and benefits of prescription drugs.
Again, that means:
* 60% of doctors believe patients do not understand possible risks.
* 65% of doctors believe DTC ads confuse patients about risks and benefits.
Doctors do not believe that patients understand risks from seeing the ad.
> If the patient then decides the risks are worth it, and the doctor thinks the drug will help, the doctor writes a prescription.
Again, the study disagrees with your conclusions here. Here's another direct quote:
> and many physicians felt some pressure to prescribe something when patients mentioned DTC ads.
The doctor feels the need to prescribe it, based purely on the fact that the patient mentioned an ad. The doctor may or may not think the risks are worth it, but they feel the need to sign off on any drug simply because the patient saw an ad.
> But patients then need to go and talk to the doctor, who should then clarify the risks since they are the medical professional, not the patient.
And more than half of patients are turning up to doctors, confused about the benefits and risks of the drug they saw in an ad. The doctor tries to clarify the risks, but feel the need to give something to the patient anyway.
The only benefit of the advert here, is that they are actually talking to a doctor. But they don't understand the benefits of the drug, and they don't understand the risks of the drug, they just want something they saw on TV.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct-to-consumer_advertising adds Hong Kong, and that's it.
I'm always astonised when I'm in the US at the medical ads on TV. It seems bizarre that companies target advertising at the consumer for products that should really be selected on their behalf by a medical professional.
And those disclaimer/warning crack me up.
News to me. ;-)
For example, thousands of deaths have been attributed to the tough drug approval requirements in the US. How would you feel if you had a terminal condition and your government didn't allow you to even know of a possible treatment, or the choice of taking the risk that the treatment won't work?
You still have every right to go to them and ask what they have to say.
I don't really know anyone who thinks "Remember the good old days when cigarette ads were on TV?" (that was a thing). Prescription ads on TV are a relatively recent thing anyway (really 1995 in the US), one in which a powerful lobbying group used their money and influence to help write the rules.
Many people remember the good old days when individual rights and limits on the federal government were enforced closer to US Constitutional requirements.
And since Thalidomide hundreds of thousands of Americans have died from slow drug approvals.
Beyond this, I'm too lazy right now to look up drug company kickbacks to prescribing doctors, and I'm sure there's plenty, but it would probably still occur even if mass media advertising was banned.