What downsides does it have compared to a more traditional environment? I'm a C# developer so Xamarin sounds really tempting, it's just that I don't want to break my head on "simple" stuff I could easily avoid with a traditional environment
But from my (little) experience on it, getting to an app running and start working on it is way mire easy than with the Java approach. Give it a try :)
But overall it's much better. And you get:
Shared models with your web api, reusable business for iOS and Windows, great tools like ReSharper, and so on.