Is there an ideal amount of productivity inequality?
Even with 100% tax rates, the productive can find dimensions where it is possible to earn more, usually fame, status, non-taxable goods and political power.
Is there an ideal amount of productivity inequality?
Even with 100% tax rates, the productive can find dimensions where it is possible to earn more, usually fame, status, non-taxable goods and political power.
Technically, rent seeking comes up in situations where a private individual is capturing the value created through, eg, public infrastructure. The public can take this value for themselves through a land tax.
The profit made from maintaining a productive asset isn't considered 'rent'. So, for example, renting out a house is not necessarily rent seeking behavior (!!) because the landlord is maintaining the house. The rent-seeking part is when the rent is raised because a new local train station opens.
In this slightly technical instance, eliminating rent seeking, by definition, is likely to reduce the income to the those who are not adding any value. The behavior that is dis-incentivised was, again by deffinition, never economically productive. Economically productive investment (ie, capitalism) is supposedly untouched. Investors and retirees have to reallocate their investments into productive ventures instead of rent seeking, hopefully at no loss to their income.
The theory and practice might not be the same thing, I'm no economist.
"In economics and in public-choice theory, rent-seeking involves seeking to increase one's share of existing wealth without creating new wealth." (My emphasis)
We live in a time where those that take most, likely need it least and also often take from those that need it most, but often have least.
Of course pure rent-seeking is pretty rare, and most middlemen do provide at least some value e.g. doing market research and helping interested parties find each other. But in some cases they gain an entrenched position and start taking larger cuts purely because they can. An ideal free market would correct that through emergence of a competitor, but in the real world that is often prevented through lobbying for regulations in favor of the rent-seeker.
Plus, as the population of western world is aging and there are more and more old people and less productive young people, the rent-seeking will only get worse. Much more people will be retired and will depend on getting cut from productive working people who will be squeezed more and more (higher taxes, longer hours, lower or stagnating wages). This can be alleviated to a degree by western corporations being global and exploiting cheap labour in third world but even that will be exhausted once the developing world catches up to western standard.
The changing demographics are certainly a problem, but assuming the population trends continue, today's young people aren't particularly worse off. Their pension contributions may be used for more than one old person, but once they become old themselves, the next younger generation will be in exactly the same situation.
There's quite a bit of effort that goes into selecting a good place to invest. And, there's also a whole lot of risk involved. Look at Y Combinator, or other VCs and angel investors, for example. If investments count as "rent-seeking behavior", eliminating it would nearly destroy the economy.
People often fail to see the value of deferred expenditure of money / capital, while criticizing rent-seeking behavior. There's real value in a person choosing not to spend their money immediately, and instead giving it to someone else.
So back then we had high tax _rates_, high investment, and low profits. Now were have low tax rates, low investment, and high profits. The thing economists don't want to you get is the amount of taxes collected remained mostly constant. The difference is in the amount re-invested vs the amount extracted.
This would collapse without rent-seeking as most old people suddenly would have to go back to work (except small minority of old people that made enough money in their lives but that will be less than 1%).
A more accurate and less ageist example is the struggling company that lobbies the government for government grants or special protections. This activity fails to create any benefit for society and in fact harms the public by redistributing resources from taxpayers to the company.
Productivity is a canard. Either labour is paid its living costs or not.
Care to elaborate? You don't think there are large variations in productive capacity among all of labour, and that higher productivity usually results in compensation far beyond living wages?
This may not apply to the majority of workers. I could see the Iron Law of Wages being true for them [1]. However, I don't think we should ignore the dynamics that we find as we move towards the edges of the spectrum.
[1] Still, I would argue that a "living wage" means different things at different times. A living wage at time period 1 could result in a significantly better quality of life than that from time period 2.
"A man must always live by his work, and his wages must at least be sufficient to maintain him. They must even upon most occasions be somewhat more; otherwise it would be impossible for him to bring up a family, and the race of such workmen could not last beyond the first generation."
https://en.m.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_...
The above statement is "totally wrong"? How can you be so sure?
As per the wikipedia description: "idea of rent-seeking was developed by Gordon Tullock in 1967.[2] The expression rent-seeking was coined in 1974 by Anne Krueger.[3] The word "rent" does not as a rule refer here to payment on a lease but stems instead from Adam Smith's division of incomes into profit, wage, and rent.[4] The origin of the term refers to gaining control of land or other natural resources." [emphasis mine]
Whether it is a pseudo "public" Government or a Private individual, the behavior of "rent-seeking" is the same, ie. resource's control.