What isn't and is politicized is not a logical deduction, nor is it rational. Its emotional.
>If you consider broadband a basic need (I do) then it makes sense
I don't think having such a simple gating mechanism for prescribing government policy makes much sense. I also consider food to be a basic need, but I don't want a government cheeseburger.
Like I said, I'm all for the public owning the last mile and then the private players compete.