Do social media threaten democracy?
economist.com
economist.com
Nicky Case made an excellent game/article about this issue. I encourage you to read it all the way through: http://ncase.me/ballot/
There are nonprofits working on this issue in the USA.[2] Personally I'm more a fan of the push to create multi-representative districts within states than I am about RCV (basically a restricted form of IRV). But regardless, if you want to get involved, call them up first.
But as population sizes increase the resources of parties become critical. And as voters become more and more disconnected from their representatives, the value of having a symbol by your name becomes much more important than what you actually believe, and in some cases the former actually ends up redefining the latter. In any case the fact that nearly everybody at most all levels is a republican or democrat even though fewer people than ever actually identify as republican or democrat, is something that I would call very strong evidence of a systemic problem in our electoral system.
That's why russia, china, europe and now we are working so hard to control social media.
It's threatens russian establishment propaganda. It threatens chinese establishment propaganda. It threatens western establishment propaganda. There is a reason why the media is attacking social media so vociferously.
[1] http://www.mintpressnews.com/counterpunch-google-censors-blo...
The fact is that they don't, that the platforms have been very much wide open to manipulation, that the founders and executives of the companies have denied that there is any such problem, and that malicious agents have subverted the systems and through them social and political dynamics.
Your last paragraph frankly makes your first nonsensical. Either ensuring a sound epistemic and media system is good, or it is not. You're trying to have it both ways. The fact that manipulating media for control and influence is undertaken is very widely recognised, and has been for millennia.
How?
> You're trying to have it both ways.
No. I'm explaining why all governments and all propaganda organizations want to control social media.
It's why china banned facebook and why they are building their own internal/national social media platforms. The same thing with russia.
> The fact that manipulating media for control and influence is undertaken is very widely recognised, and has been for millennia.
I know. That's my point.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15628132
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15628471
It's funny how media outlets are scrambling to state what was obvious at the very least a couple years ago but it's also kind of scary. It's great people are waking up to this, but worried about some kind of overreach based on emotion which limits not just the big players but also further innovation.
Is that a sign of incompetent media? Why do media outlets wait to talk about an issue until everyone else is, versus doing some kind of investigative research and informing their readers ahead of time? They seem way behind the curve.
In its print edition, The Economist begins with a set of "leaders" -- brief introductions to a topic, for which there's almost always a much more detailed briefing.
The first item you link appears to be the corresponding briefing to the leader I've posted here.
As if the fact that Russia may have funded it matters at all.
How would it be any different if the NYT distributed the same material?
Given that, showing that some Russians who may or may not have had some ties to Putin's government posted misinformation on Facebook seems a bit irrelevant. Anyone can post misinformation. In your analogy my prized possessions are heaped in the middle of a field 2 hours outside of town.
because of a high percentage of the population being present, there is now substantial power to be had by influencing the discussions that take place.
Source: https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/RCyGi3HQ...
Discussion: https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/5wg0hp/when_ep...
What she said, in conjunction with a lot of thinking and research on my part makes me realise that media, communications, politics, and economics always have been very, very tightly interconnected, though we seem to like pretending this isn't the case, or that the consequences don't matter.
(This ties into another observation: that masterminds are very often not so much evil and geniuses as uninhibited. And that removal of inhibitions can come through various mechanisms, including ignorance, stupidity, and denial. I suspect several of these are at play, and Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg in particular has been slow to realise that connecting a few billion not-entirely-BFFs might reveal some interesting dynamics.)
What a still-in-process review of the field of media studies and philosophy is turning up is the fact that very nearly every major revolution in communications has resulted in massive and often painful or devastating disruptions to social order. We see this in the written record going back to the origin of the written record itself, and there's anthropological evidence to suggest that speech may also have contributed to an accelerated divergence between various proto-human clades.
Writing, maths, accounting, insurance and risk, printing, calculus, literacy, telegraph, telephone, phonographs, radio, cinema, television, and subsequent technologies have each produced major shifts in political and military systems. Printing and literacy are associated with the Protestant Reformation (just celebrating its 500th anniversary this week), the 30 Years War, arguably the American Revolution -- the first of the modern revolutions -- and the French and many revolutions of the 19th and early 20th centuries.
The rise of Fascism is very tightly tied to the emergence of radio, public address and recording equipment (Germany remains a centre of excellence for same), and mass distribution of cheap books. Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-tung (a/k/a "The Little Red Book") rivals the Bible as the most published book of all time, with estimates ranging from 2 - 6.5 billion copies printed.
And Facebook can reach two billion people worldwide. It is quite literally the single largest media platform ever developed, with global and instant reach.
The thought that parties interested in power, manipulation, or disruption wouldn't seek to influence this is ... frankly, idiotic.
And the truth that the impacts of any such manipulation extend far beyond the management and beneficial shareholders of Facebook, Google, Twitter, Reddit, etc., is a, pardon, trumping argument for why these platforms must be regulated.