When managers are faced with stack ranking employees, they will often decide based on factors not purely related to the productivity or value of the employee.
----
That, and as an employee in a stack-ranked organization, you know you need to be competitive. Not in terms of productivity but in terms of "in the eyes of your manager"-- Perception is more important than performance.
Studies have shown that men compete more aggressively than women, on average. So it's certainly plausible that men enjoy a gender-driven advantage that isn't purely due to gender-discrimination. Rather, it is the system that is biased.
This reminds me of that "racist algorithm" debacle.
[0] https://hbr.org/2017/10/a-study-used-sensors-to-show-that-me...
I can appreciate that. It's almost certainly true. Most people are biased.
The point of my comment wasn't argue differently, or to defend Uber or their managers, but to show how choosing a sexist system is the same as being sexist, in effect.
People have good reason to be doubtful of social sciences, and the replication crisis has only gotten worse now affecting biological science.
https://www.nature.com/news/over-half-of-psychology-studies-...
Studies have also shown that when women exhibit identical "aggressive" behavior as men, they are labeled more negatively than their male counterparts.
The specific problem with stack ranking is the one-on-one ranking method. I'm absolutely convinced that I myself would succumb to all sorts of biases when asked to rate people like that: I'd tend to think the silent, introvert guy who stays late and has no fashion sense is smarter than the outgoing jock leaving at 5pm sharp to be with his family. I'd somehow convince myself that the guy I enjoy eating lunch with is more important than the Belgian guy who doesn't speak english well enough to socialise... The article makes a similar point: “My observation was whoever was the best orator got their people ranked higher.”
On aggregate, it's quite obvious that these biases could amount to gender-specific discrimination, even if not a single evaluator had gender on their minds.
[0] For some reasonable value of "never"
[1] https://hbr.org/2017/10/a-study-used-sensors-to-show-that-me...