So "as a society" applies here, in the loose sense of government decision-making.
There's no market in the abstract - there are courts, tax laws, civil laws, and many other things that mediate.
So "as a society" applies here, in the loose sense of government decision-making.
There's no market in the abstract - there are courts, tax laws, civil laws, and many other things that mediate.
I think the tax thing is a huge misconception that just isn't backed up by reality. The US still has a progressive tax system, even after taking into account the many rules (or the mysterious and nefarious "tax breaks" that everyone alludes to).
The top 1% have around 20% of the income, but pay 40% of the federal income taxes!
Real federal income tax rate paid:
Top 1% - 27%
Top 5% - 23%
Top 10% - 21%
Top 25% - 18%
Top 50% - 16%
Bottom 50% - 3.45%
https://taxfoundation.org/summary-latest-federal-income-tax-...
PS: Social Security pays money for blind people who have never worked, it's in no way a just a 'retirement' fund and is simply general welfare under a new name.
The top 5% pay 53% of all federal taxes including social security and Medicaid.[1]