We should not allow billionaires.
We should not allow billionaires.
How do we make sure he has the resources to build and fund that business, while denying him the funds and resources to do other legal activities as well? Who gets to decide yes you can spend billions on building Facebook, but no you can’t spend it on real estate that’s legal for other people to buy? How do we restrict that by law and ensure the people enforcing those restrictions don’t kill off the next Facebook, or the next holiday resort company, etc? Command economies don’t have much of a track record of economic success.
I say all that without even liking Facebook, I barely use it and am annoyed by a lot of their business practices, but I have no right to tell people which company they should work for or which social network they should use or what company or project allowed by the law that they should or should not fund.
Capitalism is ultimately about the individual freedom of citizens to spend or invest their money as they see fit. How do you justify taking away those freedoms and how to you do so without choking off innovation and growth?
Of course Zuck should reap more rewards for his founding and leadership role. But not to the tune of 75 billion dollars.
And it should not require billion-dollar paydays to incentivize people to build companies.
Why should he be forced to relinquish control or equity in his company if literally everyone he worked with agreed to the terms of their employment at his company? Who is the person that should decide “oh, at this point he has enough, he doesn’t deserve more”? You? Some other corrupt government individual?
I just don’t understand why you think that random people should be able to determine the fate of a fortune that someone amassed when they had nothing to do with it.
He pays his taxes. Facebook pays their taxes as required by law. Why do you think that’s not enough? I understand closing loopholes, but you apparently think we should go further? You think that we should set a hard cap on wealth? How would that not create adverse economic incentives?
Also, I'm not confused about people agreeing to their compensation terms. That's true and not the issue, any more than royalty was "ok" because for many hundreds of years, people were ok with it.
There's a funnel that leads to one human being having over 75-million times more than another. We tolerate this today. And here in the tech world, we make apologies for it (even while many still manage to scoff at Wall St)
Your whole argument seems to come from the viewpoint that wealth is zero-sum.. when it so obviously isn’t.
Until you can answer these questions, how do you expect anyone to take your position seriously?
Countries that tried to do without economies like ours though, such as Soviet Russia, China under Mao, Venezuela and Cuba today, etc didn't do so well. So how do you confiscate the majority of the capital in society that is used to generate all this wealth without killing the goose that's laying the golden eggs? But if you do allow the accumulation of capital so that it can be deployed efficiently, how do you prevent free people in a democracy from using that capital for other things too?
How do you restrict individual freedom for people like Zuckerberg while meeting your social engineering goals?
Still waiting for even a perfunctory attempt to actually answer my questions with anything other than meaningless platitudes.
I’d rather have a worse performing economy with low income disparity than what we have, without a second thought.
Advancements are made regardless of the fantastical sums awarded just the very few on top.
You also don't need to be socialist to fix the inequality problems.
And simply, there are too many mathematical power laws in any society to prevent the few from having a lot. The intensity is what you need to change. It's difficult.
Assuming you’re not living in a socialist democracy but rather a dictatorship, I feel they often become confused and just wanted to point that out.
Norway has more billionaires per capita than the US.
Societies that aren't hierarchical don't really exist on any but the tiniest scales excluding some situations where individual units are nearly self-sufficient.
Please make a difference between a socialist-leaning societal culture and an actual totalitarian government necessary to force everyone to follow socialist policies. The socialism you're thinking of starts when you abolish elections (or make it the law that you have to vote for The Party) and merge the three branches of government. Simply enacting socialist policies for the benefit of the community within the established democratic framework of checks and balances on the power of governing bodies, is not a slippery slope and does not end with actual socialism.
I have collected some context about the largest private landowner on each of the Hawaiian islands, which I believe people may find interesting. They are sorted in (decreasing) order by size of the island.
Kamehameha Schools owns ~12% of the ~10,000 square kilometers of (the big island of) Hawai`i.
Alexander & Baldwin owns ~20% of the ~1,900 square kilometers of Maui.
Kamehameha Schools (same as above) owns ~12% of the ~1,500 square kilometers of O`ahu.
The Robinson family owns ~15% of the ~1,400 square kilometers of Kaua`i. (This is probably the island intended by my parent comment, as Mark Zuckerberg owns ~3 square kilometers there, or 1/500th of the island.)
Molokai Ranch owns ~35% of the ~700 square kilometers of Moloka`i. It is currently for sale for $260 million: http://www.businessinsider.com/hawaiian-island-for-sale-molo...
Larry Ellison owns ~97% of the ~360 square kilometers of Lana`i (under the name "Pulama Lanai").
The Robinson family (same as above) owns ~99% of the 180 square kilometers of Ni`ihau.
There are no private landowners on the ~115 square kilometers of the smallest of the eight traditional Hawaiian islands, Kaho`olawe.
Of course, that's probably also a good way to get systems and things which are...well, designed by committee.
If there are 20 burger restaurants, the best burger isn't designed by committee. Each will try to improve to stay in the market and the people who decide who survives and who dies is determined by the people choosing which burger to eat.
It works as long as there is competition. One burger restaurant winning all of the business with a great burger, and then using scale to make competition impossible followed by lowering the quality to find minimum cost with maximum profit... that's another outcome of capitalism, and one we're suffering now.
To make it work you need centralized authority that resists corruption and can put it's finger on the scale to encourage the appropriate amount of diversity.
Instead you should be thinking "how do I/we get these obviously capable and motivated people to act in a way that benefits all of us". Zuckerberg didn't steal the money by overt force (what the socialist government used to do to us in East Europe), there was a long line of economic exchanges that benefited both parties in some way, that let him get to where he is. He started high, yes, and he reached even higher. The fact he's now acting churlish should not be cause for you to ask for the abolishment of basic human rights and liberties.
Amassing $75B is not a basic human right or liberty. And this has nothing at all do with someone acting churlish, or conversely with their potential to do wonderful things with that money.
The question is just: as a society, do we allow a roomful of people to own more than half the nation combined? And how does this benefit the country?
I say No — the disparity must be reined in.
So for your example you call out trench diggers, hardware engineers, assemblers, electrical engineers etc... Each of these groups is getting paid for their services based on market competition. As far as I know, a good portion of those are unionized and the rest are in competitive industries that supply multiple different partners. Eg. very few of those laborers work as direct employees of Facebook - they take relatively short term contracts to execute those tasks and then move on to other customers.
I'm not sure how you see equity being distributed in those cases such that it would be considered fair.
The "modern economic" argument is that the price they are being paid - arguably negotiated against other competitors is market clearing.