Sorry if it's a naive question. My experience with C is limited.
Sorry if it's a naive question. My experience with C is limited.
90% of your program performance is going to be dominated by cache usage(unless you're doing something really dumb). With C you can place things next to each other explicitly so that your prefetcher/etc is automatically pulling in the data you need to the L1 cache.
Any ref'd/GC'd language is going to make that really hard(not impossible, but you have to jump through a million hoops like sun.misc.unsafe in Java).
Look up Data Oriented Design if you're interested in this stuff, Mike Acton does a great job covering it.
All it takes is 4-5 of these and now you're incurring performance hit of ~1ms which gets you into SSD territory[1].
As always, profile before making these optimizations but the OP was asking why something like this isn't possible in managed languages.
[1] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/06/insid...
Not true at all.
Oberon, Active Oberon, Component Pascal, Modula-2+, Modula-3, D, System C#, Nim all offer ways to manually control memory outside GC control, just like C and C++.
Glad to provide Modula-3 examples to any C tricks you might want to do, or in D if you prefer something more modern.
Note that I didn't say that it was impossible, just that the ergonomics of GC'd languages don't tend to focus on performance in the ways that languages with explicit memory control do.
GC systems programming languages offer exactly the same explicit control as C does, in unsafe memory blocks.
Do you want to shot yourself like C in Modula-3? Declare a variable as UNTRACED REF, 100% like a C pointer.
Do you want a C union? Declare a tagged RECORD type.
Do you want a packed record to fill you cache line? Compiler alignment pragmas.
Allocation of value types on the stack or global memory section? Great, it is the default allocation type.
Bit fiddling to prepare a statically allocated buffer for a DMA transfer? UNSAFE code section.
Yet you just talked past my point to give some sort of soliloquy about Modula-3.
It doesn't matter how those languages died, it just matters that they did. The ecosystem and number of people who know how to write a language is almost, if not more important than the language when it comes to shipping software.
We should not think of Java when comparing system programming languages with GC against C.
Yes, the languages you mention meet all the technical requirements(congrats, here's your 10 internet points) it doesn't matter if I can't find people who know how to write it.
Since you seem to want to avoid talking about anything I raise I don't think it's productive to continue this conversation.
For example, all the work with System C# done in Midori has been being applied to C#, with .NET Native, ref returns, local ref variables, value tuples, regions with disabled GC, memory slices, with a few more down the roadmap, like effectively manual memory management presented at OOPSLA 2017.
Or the ongoing @nogc and BetterC improvements in D, Wallmart, EBay, Netflix, Remedy Games among many others, seem to be able to find people that know how to write it.