Maybe you’re like an evil hypnotist. “You will stop following your diet. You will stop following your diet. You will stop following your diet.” :-)
Seriously though — I think these two claims are both frequent and harmful:
1. It’s impossible to stay disciplined in the long run.
2. Discipline sucks the joy out of life. On the contrary, I think discipline gives you freedom.
Anyway, I don't see how you shattered anything.
First of all, I never attempted to do GTD exactly because I never saw the value. So I didn't fail at it I simply decided not to do it once I realized what it required.
Second of all that you have used GTD for years doesn't mean you are going to continue using it. Lets talk in 10 years and see.
Saying "be disciplined" is roughly in the same category as telling someone to "be happy". It's a great goal, but no help at all for someone who is not already there.