What all these sites have in common is that they provide the visitor with something they want. No need for fancy graphics if you have something to offer that they cannot get elsewhere (for free).
What all these sites have in common is that they provide the visitor with something they want. No need for fancy graphics if you have something to offer that they cannot get elsewhere (for free).
Plentyoffish was one of the first / earliest online dating site which went free, when all competitors charged a fee. Thus making it the first / earliest in that category.
These days the internet is saturated with free dating services.
I just felt, that the author mistakenly picked a bunch of sites which had an edge (of being in the early web) and therefore aesthetics didn't matter to get a following.
I feel there are plenty of examples of modern sites / services that are new and demonstrate the keeping it simple / clean design perfectly well!
There was also the fact that he says Google's biggest selling point was its simple design. Yes Google's simple design was a breath of fresh air compared to the cluttered yahoo portals of the world. However Google's biggest selling point was that it's search algorithms were undeniably brilliant.
The quality of the searches you got in Google beat any competitor and that's why many (including myself) made the switch!.
Success came from being an early entrant into the SEO game and recognizing ahead of others that AdWords could support a totally free site.
If you go and find the founders blog you can track the entire process of the site (like BingoCreator), including his girlfriend holding a (2 month) paycheck from google adsense for $450,000
Where Plenty of Fish succeeds more than thousands of similarly ugly ad-based sites is by being big enough, useful enough and famous enough for people to come back.