Political theorist James Scott thinks civilization is overrated
vox.com
vox.com
Nobody has read _all of hacker news_. Can't there be a place for re-posts, if not on the main page?
Often, the top 50 or so posts will remain relatively static for days, while posts like this never make it far enough up the rankings for to actually see them.
I realise some people will be more marginal to the concept of being a hippy-anti-civilisation hunter gatherer... but regardless, the answers given by the interviewee were well reasoned and objective, I thought most HN reader would have appreciated them. The title however is poor and misleading.
My version is less catchy, I admit.
Scott has also written "Seeing Like A State", a great book about, in its own words, "how certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed" - in particular, grand schemes by powerful central governments which forced pre-existing social and ecological arrangements into a form more understandable to central management, but in the process lost some essential flexibility.
Also related, an older piece in the same vein as "Against the Grain" is Jared Diamond's short essay "The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race": http://www.ditext.com/diamond/mistake.html (Jared Diamond is also not an archaeologist, however. I'm curious what archaeologists have to think about this line of reasoning in general.)
Are we talking about the mean happiness of all humans at one instant? If that’s our only goal, maybe we can achieve it by killing or sterilizing everyone below a certain level of happiness, but obviously that goes against most people’s moral beliefs.
Or are we talking about maximizing the sum of all humans’ happiness? If that’s our only goal, maybe we can achieve it by maximizing birth rates and thus maximizing the human population regardless of each human’s quality of life, but obviously that also goes against most of our moral beliefs. Perhaps we can get around this reductio ad absurdum by allowing for negative happiness values, e.g. for people born into starvation or poverty, but calculating an absolute utility value for each human is difficult or impossible anyway (which affects all of these proposals).
Or how about Pareto efficiency? If our only goal is to achieve a state wherein no one’s happiness can be increased without decreasing someone else’s happiness, that could perhaps be achieved by having one rich despot on whom everyone else is dependent, which again goes against most people’s moral beliefs.
Granted, I suspect most people reading this would have the same gut reaction as me: to choose being born to random parents now. But how much of that is influenced by our experiences with and dependence on modern society? Most readers of this comment are probably well above the current global average of quality of life according to any plausible definition. Perhaps people currently living in poverty would have different gut reactions to the proposal.
It’s outside the scope of this article, but the question could be extended into the future, where we have even less data (none). Would you rather be born to random parents now, or random parents some period in the future?
>Are we talking about the mean happiness of all humans at one instant? If that’s our only goal, maybe we can achieve it by killing or sterilizing everyone below a certain level of happiness, but obviously that goes against most people’s moral beliefs.
While the interviewer was clearly pushing for comparisons of happiness in modern civilisation, I don't feel that either participant in the conversation were attempting to rigorously quantify it... That would seem as fruitless an endeavour as attempting to quantify broad intelligence. The details are not only subjective, but in this case likely to group quite disparate "wants" for happiness due to experiencing an entirely different lifestyles. They are not all (or hardly at all) directly comparable, but it's interesting to contemplate the differences to see what we have gained and lost.
In relation to happiness: the most interesting "correction" discussed is how the transition to agriculture clearly and quantifiably did _not_ provide an immediate improvement in quality of life (and most likely by proxy happiness), bone records show that undernourishment was an effect of becoming an early member of agricultural society.
We tend to think of hunter gathers as we used to think about neanderthals (as being obsolete, rather than simply different). Civilisation clearly has many advantages that are not possible in a hunter gatherer society, but even in it's evolved form mostly void of the initial malnutrition and disease has many side effects which are not present in hunter gatherer society that are not necessarily advantages. Likewise hunter gatherer lifestyles have advantages that are not practically possible in modern civilisation.
I guess my point is, they are different, and it's important to think of them as different rather than obsolete and degenerate as most people do... even trying to compare them in terms of crude quantifiers such as "happiness" seems wrong in this sense (for better or worse).
Your comment in that context is attacking a straw man of what GP wrote.
> Myself, and apparently most of the western world, we'd rather give up those liberties for the massive benefits that we get in exchange.
Never mind that this is a blatant false dichotomy, there is no such choice offered.
It got progressively worse, by the 18th century it got to be a reason for killing people, something that in the 20th was done to tens of millions.
And the funny bit is that the theorists behind the mass murders had stated that "historical progress" was inevitable anyways. Blood sacrifices to hurry up the tide, how quaint ...
But both groups make their beliefs into reasons for killing people. The left kills people it thinks stand in the way of progress towards utopia. The right kills people it thinks threaten the purity or safety of what has already been built.
Conversely, there are plenty of anti-technology people on the left. I follow Urban planning, there are strong advocates for more traditional forms of transportation such as cycling and trains, and those are generally regarded to be left of centre views. Environmentalism is a deeply conservative movement, but in the twisted times we live in, those people for some reason fall left of centre.
And plenty of people from all parts of the political spectrum are simply exploiting the intuitions of their "tribe" for status advantages.
The very idea of historical progress is a modern construct.
Reading Sapiens will make you feel and sound like you know what you are talking about. And therefore it is for people who cannot put in the thirty years to feel like subject matter experts.
It's like what Jon Stewart/Rush Limbaugh and their clones do for their fan clubs.
So 99.9% of everybody? That sounds more like a recommendation than a criticism.