A case for prohibition of
both alcohol
and hallucinogens can be rational, but for the popularity of alcohol making it untenable to enforce that prohibition. In that set of circumstances, a prohibition targeting hallucinogens alone can still be rational even if the harm from alcohol is comparable.
The point, of course, is that comparable harm from alcohol is not dispositive in the discussion of a ban on hallucinogens.
Obviously, the notion that LSD is no more harmful than whiskey is also not broadly accepted in our public policy, or really the public policy of most western countries. So there's (at least) two hurdles for your argument to clear. But I'm stipulating the latter argument, because it's the logic you're employing that bugs me, not the equivalence you're trying to draw.
These are positive arguments, not normative ones.