The real problem is if you wanted to go farther gassing up the Saturn takes five minutes, and gassing up the Tesla will take... 30 minutes? If there's nobody using the charger?
And it's not clear to me just how easy it will be to use a supercharger if Tesla sells as many as they intend. How likely is it I'll get a slot without waiting the week of Thanksgiving?
My situation can't be that uncommon. People take vacations, visit family, go to conventions, etc, etc. I realize if it's just once or twice a year you could rent a car, but it doesn't take that many rentals to put you into the "wish I'd bought a regular car" group.
The only way I can see a car like that making sense is if you're part of a two-car family and the electric is a dedicated commuter.