I don't want to keep the wiki page super busy, so I now keep a text file with basically a much more verbose version of the same thing. What happened, what I tried, what I eventually found was the root cause, how I fixed it, and what I'm changing to prevent a repeat.
This has two big advantages. First, the obvious one is that when things act up I can sometimes find details on a previous incident that I don't remember very well. The second and I think even greater advantage, though, is that it forces me to actually think seriously about the root cause and preventative measures every single time, instead of just fixing the immediate problem and then going on to the next thing in a rush.