There is currently a huge kerfuffle going on in Germany, with most universities canceling their Elsevier subscription because Elsevier doesn't do true open access.
As a scientist, I can only thank goodness for Sci Hub. It is so insulting to go through a grueling review, be expected to do reviews myself for free, then pay thousands of dollars for publishing a pdf, and then pay additional thousands of dollars for accessing my peers works. What a mess.
(My own experience is that American schools are too fixated on the names of the journals, but less concerned with the company that publishes the journal. So it would still be pretty tough to break the current model, although not as difficult as it would be with Europe.)
In this it is comparable to those copy protection schemes of old which made paying users jump through hoops while the pirates just had smooth sailing all the way. Arrrrrr!