The difference between your situations is probably meaningful because industry perceives CS students and self-taught web developers differently when it comes to entry level jobs. For example entry level jobs at places with Glass Door reviews are far more open to the CS student than a self taught web developer. A self taught web developer is more likely to land an opportunity in a local web-shop than at a big company or a startup. For the self taught web developer, applying for a first entry level job at Google or Apple or Uber or Github is a waste of time.
CS students tend to get a pass when it comes to the problem of finding great developers. [1] Self taught web developers tend not to.
[1]: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2006/09/06/finding-great-deve...