A novel use for unpaired left shoes
mindyourdecisions.com
mindyourdecisions.com
Can you think of a use for an unpaired left shoe?
Sure, if the matching right shoes are also available. That's the whole point of the anecdote, which is so absurd as to most certainly be an Urban Legend.
My friend’s father ordered a huge shipment of sneakers from a U.S. company with the stipulation that all the left-footed shoes be packaged separately from all the right-footed shoes. The left-footed shoes were to be shipped to Bombay, and 60 days later the right-footed shoes were to be shipped to Calcutta.
Step 1: I buy X thousand shoes for a price of Y$/pair, and probably pay a little over the regular market price, because I want special handling, and double postage.
The shipment sent to Bombay went unclaimed, so after 30 days it was auctioned off
Step 2: I fail to claim the shoes when they arrive. I now am out the money I paid for the shoes, and have no shoes.
Because no one could think of a use for a huge shipment of left-footed sneakers, no one bid against my friend’s father and he picked up these shoes for next to nothing.
Step 3: I now pay for these shoes again.
Step 4: Profit!
Naturally, I can try to get out of paying for the shoes in step 1, but then our story would simply be one of fraud.
The strategy is ingenious, and it reminds me that a savvy businessperson is someone that can see value where others see none.
Quite the opposite, really.
It's as if the shoes were smuggled into India in plain sight. Presumably the cost of buying the 'useless' shoes at auction came to less than the import duty.
The profit comes from the fact that the money paid in step 3 is less than what would have been paid in import duties had he collected the shoes in step 2. And then, having successfully imported shoes at below the cost that other entrepreneurs were capable of getting, he was able to resell those shoes at below market rates and still have a higher profit margin.
If he paid more for special handling, that would have been covered. If the shipments were big enough, then postage is based on some combination of weight and volume. This is unchanged.
@maushu, the real solution here is to get rid of the dumb trade barriers in the first place. The 'problem' of dodging round them pales into insignificance in comparison, if indeed it is a problem at all. Presumably a lot of Indian politicians thought the way you did, until policies changed, and India started growing.
@davidw "To do otherwise leads to corruption and disdain for the rule of law."
Maybe, but bad laws do that too. In the real world, people want to get things done rather than go into politics to replace the eedjits that are stopping them.
You can hit the 'reply' link to reply to comments.
In reply to your observation that people "just want to get stuff done" - great, they can elect politicians who will try and make it possible to do so. Otherwise, they should obey the law. It's there (or should be) so that one person's "getting stuff done" doesn't impinge on the rights of other people, or society as a whole. Clearly, people have different ideas about what laws are just and so on, but just ignoring whatever laws don't suit your fancy is not a recipe for a healthy place to live.
Case in point, the province of Nova Scotia was one of the last places in North America to ban shopping on Sundays. An exception was made for stores under a certain square-footage. After unsuccessfully lobbying the government to overturn the ban, the major grocery stores started re-branding themselves as shopping malls and registering the deli, produce, fish market, etc. as separate businesses which fell under the square footage requirements. Soon after they started doing this, the government caved and overturned the law.
I don't see it as breaking the law so much as demonstrating that it can't effectively be enforced.
I suppose it's not always cut and dried, but what I see in Italy is a broad disregard for rules and laws, and it's a very unpleasant aspect of the country.
Rosa Parks deliberately violated the law - this was a direct challenge, and one justified because the law was not just bad, but intentionally malicious.
Whereas the supermarket guys are quite blatant in what they're doing to the point where the local government either had to relent or crack down.
Deliberately subverting the law should not be commended. But in this example, he was able to work around the deleterious effect of a bad law while fully adhering to its provisions. I can't see a problem with this.
The way the law is enforced is very much a function of what it says. I'm fairly confident in assuming that the customs authority didn't arbitrarily make up the "auction goods with duties unpaid for 30 days" rule, and that it was fully rooted in applicable law.
Now, there are plenty of loopholes in the law but, just as you can get a speeding ticket while traveling below the posted speed limit in a blizzard the basic rules are usually still enforceable. The law may go to great detail about what how and why to post a given speed limit, but they are only guidelines. EX: A friend was given a speeding ticket by a cop who did not know how fast he was going AND did not know what the speeding limit was on that road. However, the Judge decided that the cop as an expert witness and he had to pay the fine.
PS: You often see the same sorts of things in IRS audits, because you don’t get to just follow 95% of the rules.
And high import tariffs are much more likely to be protectionist than to be legitimate revenue sources - raising the tax rates wouldn't be a sensible response for a protection tariff.
Well, the story still is simply one of fraud. I think a judge would easily side with the tax authorities if it came to delivering an opinion on this cute little 'hack'.
Sounds like an urban myth, anyway...
Ford does this today with the Transit: they install a cheap back seat in Europe, ship the cars to the States, and convert them back to cargo in a garage next to the docks, all to save on import duties. That even creates some jobs in order to game the system, and the tax Ford is getting around is stupid to begin with, but no one in their right mind can call this productivity or value.
ping pong paddles
toy river boats (place a candle in them and let them flow down the river)