Are you planning to uncap benefits? If you do, Ross Perot gets $400k/year. If you don't, rich people start caring about SS. Those are the reasons why Social Security advocates used to like the cap. Were they wrong?
FWIW, SS payouts are very progressive. Folks on the low end get a reasonable return on their contributions. Folks near/at the cap get a crappy deal. The rich ones don't care because of the cap.
Edit: This would also really help out aging athletes / rock stars / actors who make a lot of money when they are young and then run out.
Crappy payout was assumed in the "Ross Perot gets $400k/year".
It has two huge political problems - folks will scream about large payouts to rich folk and rich folk will fight the crappy ROI.