If the US treated women more like Norway it would be $1.6 trillion richer
qz.com
qz.com
I would definitely believe the idea that including more women in the work force will help us be richer but i don't see much data in the article suggesting this. I see data showing how woman are under represented, and how in Norway they're not and norway has a strong GDP. But that is one data point. But the title says the US WOULD be $1.6 trillion richer.
Also worth pointing out i'm no economist, please enlighten me if i'm misunderstanding.
THey only mention US and norway which used to employ women in the work force at the same rate, and now they don't and had different growths in the GPD. That is true but it is TWO DATA POINTS. It seems they are drawing causation when its just a line connecting the points.
Please correct me or link me if there is more data, but this seems entirely theoretical.
"Lost Labor-Force Participation Means Lost Economic Activity" Chart 1 .
" women’s participation has also declined, to just 57% this year from roughly 60% in 2000." Chart 2.
They seem to have correlated those two charts to come up with that figure. " Pregnancy Discrimination Act of 1978, gave women greater freedom to work outside the home" is their explanation for higher rates in the past.
Interestingly though men's participation rate seems to have fallen more dramatically and seem to mirror women's trend exactly from 2000.
> Hey only mention US and norway which used to employ women in the work force at the same rate, and now they don't and had different growths in the GPD.
While we’ve singled out Norway, many other countries provide meaningful contrast to the U.S.If we were to look closer to home, Canada offers an example where women’s participation picked up dramatically a few decades ago.
I looked at canadian participation rate for women[2], I don't see "picked up dramatically" , perhaps I am looking at it wrong.
The US is on a very short list of countries that have no national paid maternity leave:
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/jul/...
The actual assertion in the article is a simple matter of doing the math:
If women entered and stayed in the workforce at the same rate as they did in Norway, the US economy would be $1.6 trillion larger than it is today, according to economists at S&P.
I cannot fathom why this is even being questioned, but perhaps that is partly because I have read a lot on such subjects over the years. Yes, we know for a fact that you can create policies and practices that raise female participation in the work force. This was done very consciously and dramatically in WW2 to fill factories with women workers while the men went off to war. At that time, they frequently had on site daycare so moms could see their kids on their breaks. I sort of have firsthand experience with such an arrangement and it makes a huge difference to be able to see the kids every couple of hours and not just leave them for 8+ hours straight.
According to chart 2, men's labor force participation drop mirrors women's in that time period. Its not gender specific.
Is the idea here that we know why women's participation is dropping but men's drop is just a mystery? If its dropping across the board regardless of gender there might be other reasons. correct?
You can argue that there are confounding factors making it unclear why fewer women work (percentage wise, compared to the past), which would rebut the clickbait title. But the actual content of the article seems pretty straightforward.