Out of the Cell
granta.com
granta.com
> ...
> Marcus Aurelius had given me all kinds of wisdom for dealing with loss – impeccable in theory – and Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar had taught me about the fury of the irrational. But when I thought of texts like that, I was back in the mind of my schoolboy days, and that was the structure that now lay in rubble.
> ...
> As a writer, I’ve come to feel that the best thing I can share with readers is not dazzling argumentation, or references to the classics, but those moments we all know when we sit, helpless, before ravenous flames, or sense that we can only bow before those turns along the road, harrowing and uplifting, we will never begin to understand.
Is the author really claiming that all that fancy book learning is overrated because it didn't emotionally prepare the author for having his house burn down? Does he really think reading the sorts of emotional retrospectives like the present one would have prepared him?
I hear this argument all the time from artists: "Oh you analytical types, you spend all this time with sophisticated theories and discussion, but you don't really understand X because you haven't experienced it." Which is fine insofar as they only argue that analysis cannot fully replace first-hand experience in some human affairs. Duh. But very often they continue by arguing (either explicitly or implicitly) that consuming art somehow prepares you better. This is something that I've just never understood. Of the dramatic emotional experiences I've had, I've never thought art prepared me. Rather, I've very often thought "Wait, this is what they were talking about? This is what all those love songs (or whatever) were written about? It is completely different than I expected."
If artists were serious about accurately communicating experiences (either to prepare the viewer for ones they would later have, or to allow the viewer to know about something they could never experience), the practice of art would look a hell of a lot different. For instance, there would be much more effort made to check to see if various artistic works actually communicated things accurately by (say) studying whether viewers who had an experience were surprised by aspects of the experience despite having previously consumed the relevant art. (This is useful even if most viewers never have the true experience.)
Instead, the practice of art looks much more optimized for giving viewer intense compelling experiences without trying to maintain accuracy at all. And that's fine if that's the end goal. But they shouldn't pretend it's somehow about preparing you for life.
This is a fascinating idea. Imagine Facebook injecting various works of art into the timeline of 1 billion people (since the effect size will almost certainly be minuscule, you're going to need a large N). Then, as these people report various life experiences (ended relationship, etc), their happiness/despair/resilience scores (which are probably already being computed) could be assessed and the relationship to the art, if any, could be ascertained. (Caveat being that conducting a trial in the fashion I described would be pragmatic, but at least arguably unethical.)
If you're interested in the study of how to communicate about these things, phenomenology is a strong starting point (Dermot Moran's Intro. to Phenomenology is kinda dense unless you've studied much philosophy, but I like it.)
If you're interested maybe in a somewhat less philosophically oriented text, The Feeling of What Happens (Antonio Damasio) is a phenomenal take grounded in neurobiology.
And I think the explanation is clear: proponents of mindfulness are generally not willing to apply analytical thinking even in the service of greater mindfulness. Attempts in this direction have been made, but I have not been impressed.
https://www.amazon.ca/Buddhism-without-Beliefs-Contemporary-...
http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/09/20/meditative-states-as-me...
(The particular examples I have are from the Buddhism-specific conception of mindfulness, but I don't think the more general conceptions you allude to have been more successful. I'd be happy to see links to the contrary.)
There are certainly suggestions from other quarters (Zen, Sufism) that poetry in particular can sometimes (but rarely) trigger transient states of heightened awareness. But I'm not aware of Iyer subscribing to this.
As for analytical approaches to 'mindfulness', perhaps they're out there; I personally haven't done enough of a literature search to be sure. In a popular rather than academic vein, Sam Harris is probably as rigorous you'll get (he is always, at a minimum, very clear). Robert Wright (a secular Buddhist) has recently written a book whose title (Why Buddhism is True IIRC) strongly suggests persuasive (therefore analytical or at least purportedly rational?) intent, but I haven't read it.
But all that's a bit beside the point for most 'proponents' of mindfulness I have come across, because they are little interested in persuasion. They're not trying to argue for a Truth in the marketplace of ideas. They're just offering practices and associated reflections that might be useful to some. A curious party can pick these up and try them, and do as they wish from there. Persuasion really has no part to play.
This applies to all art. Of course it cannot literally put you in someone else's shoes, but it does things like evoke an image in the viewers imagination.
> It's up to the reader (if their curiosity is so piqued) to do their own work (whatever that may be) to see if related experiences might be relevant to them. I see nothing in this passage or in those of Iyer's works that I've read to suggest he believes anyone can attain the states he's describing simply by reading his writing.
I never denied the importance of active engagement for the viewer of art.
> They're just offering practices and associated reflections that might be useful to some.
He literally wrote "I’ve come to feel that the best thing I can share with readers is...". Not just something that might be useful, but the best. And he's arguing against analytical methods of accomplishing similar things.
I don't think this piece can be defended by saying the author was just sorta sharing some neat stuff. He's criticizing other approaches.