Mind you, there are plenty of other complaints (stability, back-compatibility, etc.) that are useful/valid regarding this software, but the above litmus serves to eliminate rather a lot of FUD and hand-wringing in my experience.
Mind you, there are plenty of other complaints (stability, back-compatibility, etc.) that are useful/valid regarding this software, but the above litmus serves to eliminate rather a lot of FUD and hand-wringing in my experience.
So yes, the same centralization/reducing-choices arguments apply to glibc.
The problem with standards compliance is that, once something becomes ubiquitous enough, its compliance begins to "drift", and replacement parts get harder to find. Is it tricky to swap out the init component of systemd with something else? Not terribly. Is it tricky to swap out its dbus messaging setup with something equivalent that can still be used by unaltered software that was previously talking via the systemd setup? Yes, a bit. And so on. For equivalent hassles regarding libcs, check out some of the FOSDEM talks from the musl folks, or the alpine folks, where they talked about the difficulties in porting software that had come to depend on the quirks of glibc.
Or just, you know, google "quirks mode" and get simultaneously nostalgic and sad :)
Paradoxically, this improves the signal of discussions about systemd's flaws, and there are plenty. With the obviously irrational/haven't-used-it/axe-to-grind stuff filtered out, it's much easier to learn about real features, problems, fixes, benefits, and drawbacks of any project, systemd included.
Actually, I replace systemd with *BSD. You know, the OS which has blessed core packages which are not replaceable?
SystemD has opaque behaviour and binary interfaces. It's the antithesis of the BSD model. Despite BSDs being quite coupled groupings of software.
Anecdotally we're attempting to move to BSDs instead of upgrading to RHEL7 due to SystemD.
... and for deployment, the Golang debugger doesn't even run on BSD at this point. So, going to have to setup new Linux (likely CentOS 6 - no systemd - or 7) boxes soon now that we're getting closer to first initial real world deployment for the project I'm on.
It's just the "UNIX is supposed to be decoupled" line that gets repeated every time systemd comes up that BSD (which, ironically, those people want to switch to) disproves.
I am running Void with musl on a Raspberry Pi 2. I love it.