Tubercular Venus: When the Beauty Standard Was Dying
deadmaidens.com
deadmaidens.com
The reason why the "tubarcular" version of beauty declined is because the rich and famous stopped dying from tuberculosis. The reason why the flappers wore far less clothing, of different material, and cut their hair short is because the rich and famous were afraid of disease carrying bacteria, not because of some proto-feminism.
We saw a similar beauty movement in the 1990s with the "heroin addict" version of beauty.
Whatever physical aspects distinguish the rich and famous are the things that become the next beauty and fashion standard.
I don't know how to take seriously an article that begins like this. Cultural notions of beauty are not part of a grand conspiracy. What an absurd claim.
I have a male friend who's far on the left side of the bell curve in terms of height, and he has shared plenty of life experience with me that contradicts precisely this (and not just in terms of his relationship to women as well, but also to peers, employers, etc.). It certainly goes both ways.
I absolutely agree (especially that beauty standards have nothing to do with oppression); however, our culture seems to take this as proof that women as a class are oppressed (optionally oppressed by men, depending on who you talk to). Of course, this is trivially refuted--life is difficult for men who wish to live outside the norm as well; however, despite being clearly false, the myth has a strong hold over our culture.
On the subject of beauty standards, it's particularly hard to make the case that they're used to oppress women given that they equally oppress men, and while I think that 'beauty' affects women more than men, it's important to note that (1) there are lots of other social factors that impact men more strongly than women and (2) this also means above-average beauty affords women more social capital than it does men.
The folks who claim that women are oppressed almost exclusively sample poorly--they focus exclusively on criteria that favor men over women or they focus on the top 10% of a distribution such that men appear favored favored for their disproportionate representation, failing to note that men are even more represented in the bottom 10%. If they're not sampling wrongly, they're looking at criteria like 'beauty' and double-dipping: beautiful women and homely women are both wronged while beautiful men and homely men are both privileged. It's hard not to conclude that the folks who hold these positions are acting in bad faith.
I don't know how we can hope to answer your question with such a blatantly biased approach.
Somehow I suspect that is not the case.
BTW, my aunt went to welding school and then had to sue the union in order to be able to get an actual job. Is a study of that sort of discrimination a sufficient counter-example to welders being overwhelmingly male, or is it just that most women don't want to be welders? It's totally true that my aunt is an unusual woman. Not only did she want to be a welder, but she was willing to sue.
I think you've missed that living within the cultural norm was pretty oppressive for women, and still can be sometimes.
Are they? Or is this a "false consciousness" argument?
Can you please expand on this? That is a very strong statement.