Spoiler alert: about four fifths of Americans end up dead, and about one third of all humans on Earth. The survivors contend with famine and plague on a scale never before seen. Most of the world's industrial capacity is destroyed.
I find it fairly easy to distinguish that scenario from the world we live in, personally.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional_Orbital_Bombardment...
> anti-ICBM missiles
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A-35_anti-ballistic_missile_sy...
> ground to space lasers
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terra-3
> "killer satellites"
Killer satellites were developed starting in the 60s and deployed operationally in 1991. It seems reasonable to think that some pre-operational capability might have existed in 1988: http://www.russianspaceweb.com/is.html
I'm not sure where the nuke satellites and lasers came from.
When it comes to answering the question of "what would a post-war world look like?" the only significant system out of these is the nuke satellites causing an EMP. That could (and probably would) have been just as easily done with standard ICBMs so I don't think it changes the answer very much.
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/secrets-out-soviets-did-not-target-cities-20120805-23ny1.html
Various other outlets and blogs at the time also made the point that, generally, both the Soviets and Americans avoided population centers as well as (IIRC) decapitation strikes.[1] They focused on strategic military targets, primarily those related to first and retaliatory nuclear strike capabilities. Basically air bases, naval bases (especially submarine bases), and related infrastructure--anything that directly supported the launch of nuclear weapons.Continental Europe, especially Germany, was an exception because of expectations of immediate ground warfare and the likelihood of tactical nukes. But arguably that's less an exception and more a variation of the same logic.
[1] Decapitation means you've nobody to negotiate with in a timely manner, ensuring the enemy will resort to unleashing every last nuclear weapon at their disposal. Neither side was stupid enough to have unleashed everything at once. All scenarios I've read described an escalation in launches over 1 or 2 days, sometimes longer, with opportunities for negotiated or even unilateral ceasefires.
Most US air and naval bases are in close proximity to population centers.
That's an Australian assessment of what they expected the Soviets to do in the 1980s.
The actual behaviour largely depends on the specific war-plan and epoch.
Actual Soviet documents from the 1950s show the Soviets planned to 'troll' the West by nuking a few non-Central-Front cities, such as Darwin or Perth, and assessing the response. Would the USA or NATO reply in kind, or back down?
> generally, both the Soviets and Americans avoided population centers as well as (IIRC) decapitation strikes
Not at all. Have a read at these US targets from one of the 1950s SIOPs:
https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/23/us/politics/1950s-us-nucl...
While many are industrial facilities, government buildings and the like, one for each city is simply designated “Population.”
In later years the targetting turned more towards counterforce ( military targets ) as the CEP of missiles crept down into the hundreds of metres. But before the mid-1980s that simply wasn't feasible
A major problem when trying to decode nuclear war strategy is that the rational thing to do after the missiles have started flying is different from the rational thing to threaten beforehand. If your goal is nuclear war, you want to threaten the enemy with complete and utter destruction from which they will never recover. Once it starts, you want to focus on the enemy's ability to attack you further, and probably ignore the enemy's civilian population and infrastructure. But it's hard to present the "total destruction" option as a credible threat unless you actually set up your forces to go through with it.
A more challenging question is - what happens when you get hundreds of warheads detonating in a small area? At a guess that number of explosions would punch its way down into the bedrock. It might even leave a lake of molten crust that would take years, if not decades, to cool.
Detonations in seismic areas might trigger huge earthquakes. (SF would be a very bad place to be.)
Whatever the outcome, it's a fair guess there would be unplanned consequences of all kinds. Most would be very negative, which makes rational (?) planning difficult.
Key quote: "It appears that two weapons targeted on a silo must arrive at least ten seconds apart to avoid fratricidal fireball effects, and less than one minute or more than one hour apart to avoid fratricidal nuclear dust cloud effects."