Ask HN: What are your thoughts about 'Star Wars: Last Jedi'? Disney's direction?
This is as divisive a movie as I've ever seen. Most people can agree that the OT was mostly rewatchable and the PT was mostly unwatchable.
At first I was surprised that it's as divisive as it is. But I think it's a franchise fraught with very personal and specific expectations from long-time fans and when that's the case, the reviews will tend to be more polarized, especially when anything new is tried.
The humorous moments were sometimes a nice touch but maybe a bit overdone. I really preferred the darker/religious type of scenes (Jedi books, the underground mirror/darkness, etc). I'm still a bit torn about the whole mind-linking thing and the Leia-space moment (trying to be vague here). But again, for me these are nitpicks, whereas they may be deal-breakers for others.