Amtrak Train Was Over Speed Limit Before It Derailed
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
train had been traveling more than
twice the speed limit before it
derailed, or at 80 miles per hour
instead of the allowable 30 m.p.h.
The only thing a locomotive engineer has to do is to manage the speed of the train[1]. Yet, whenever they kill innocent, helpless people, or cause immense damage by failing to fulfill their sole responsibility, they go unpunished. NTSB jumps in to make excuses."We need positive train control," everyone chants.
Why are the engineers needed again?
[1]: https://jobs.amtrak.com/go/Locomotive-Engineer-Jobs/400414/
I would understand if tolerances were so tight that an error of a few MPG above the limit caused the disaster. In that case, I would grant that they need more than PCT, and blame Amtrak. However, when someone is doing more than 80 MPH in a 30 MPH zone, s/he doesn't get to deflect blame to anything or anybody else.
I am impressed by NTSB's willingness to hold harmless people who do that. If a pilot were one-hundredth as reckless, s/he would not have a career.
There is also this:
A train derailed July 2 southwest of Tacoma
near Steilacoom, Wash., threatening to send
several rail cars plunging into Puget Sound.
High speed was the cause, the engineer only got suspended, presumably because no one died. I presume for every deadly accident there are at least five accidents with no deaths, and 50 close calls due to speed.Remember, the only job of the engineer is to regulate the speed of the train.
I am all for firing all the engineers if every time they kill people they will use the PCT excuse.
[1]: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2017/12/18/amtrak...
Meanwhile, it is a fact that fail-safe engineering controls would have prevented the disaster.
And what if the locomotive engineer has a heart attack, leading to a deadly accident? will you blame him?
As for heart attacks, AFAIK this has been standard equipment for ages:
Locomotives have a deadman pedal that must
be constantly pressed and periodically
released to ensure the driver is still there
and awake.[1]
So, when a train is traveling at almost three times the appropriate speed, it is being done on purpose.My argument is simple: If engineers will not be held to responsible when people die because of a speeding train, then what's the point of having an engineer?
[1]: https://www.quora.com/What-if-the-train-driver-gets-a-heart-...
on or after November 8, 1999 a working alerter
or deadman control shall be provided in the
controlling locomotive of each passenger train
operating in other than cab signal[2], automatic train[3]
control, or automatic train stop[4] territory.
[1]: https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/49/238.237[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cab_signalling#Cab_signalling_...
[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_train_control#United...
[4]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_train_stop#United_St...
Apparently positive train control (PTC) was installed for that track, and would have prevented the disaster -- but it was not enabled. That gets us one step closer to a root cause.
WSJ: "An anti-crash system for trains designed to thwart serious accidents of human error, such as derailments from over-speeding, wasn't activated, according to an Amtrak spokeswoman. The deadline to install such systems, known as positive train control [PCT], is December 2018." [1]
PCT [2] was mandated by Congress in October 2008. It was required to be deployed and activated by 2015; however in October 2015 the deadline was pushed another three years, to December 2018. [3]
Meanwhile, some form of train protection system has been operational in Europe for over one hundred years, and automated train control has been deployed in Japan since the 60s. [4]
[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/amtrak-train-derails-near-seatt...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positive_train_control
[3] https://www.politico.com/story/2015/10/congress-approves-rai...
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_train_control#Japan
Do you think these same engineers who flaunt speed limits now will be more or less likely to do dangerous things when there PTC? Does having PTC mean absolutely no chance of an accident when an engineer behaves recklessly?