Fairly sure some of these calculations are wrong or I need to get a new tax person. There is no way I will pay as little on the current bill as they think. I think it is making the current plan look way better than what I would actually pay and have been paying. This makes me distrust the what I would pay part.

Edit. In fact both of the numbers for both plans are way less than any tax bill I have seen in the last few years. I would honestly take either of those over that I actually pay.