I'm one of the people defending Apple's charge for battery replacement as reasonable, but his point is it's actually a physically difficult thing to do, to replace the battery. It takes real skill to replace a modern iphone battery without ruining it.
> "they are running them so close to the redline that they can only handle it for a year"
As for this, he's citing the fact the iPhone 7 is affected - a phone that came out just over a year ago.